Probably going to get the MSi one. Also will be getting a new PSU.
*I am aware that reviews are a horrible way to gauge a product
Also, I plan on gaming at 1080p. I have a friend who has a 9600GT that benched at ~40fps 1280x1024 in the same game I'm playing. However, he has a better CPU, so I might have some bottlenecking.
BTW: You might have seen my computer build thread. Unfortunately, I don't have the budget to do that now. However, if the opportunity opens up in the future, I might go for a better CPU and add another one of these to SLi.
The MSI is a good choice.
That one for $90 is a steal, but so is that MSI edition.