is this the call for comments thing?
I don't think so. This is a new idea of Joe's, while the call for comments thing has been around forever... and nobody yet knows what it is exactly.
and as for the whole reporting thing, haven't we been doing that? i mean look at "is AMD doomed?" and "is Intel doomed?"
those had all sorts of valuable info mixed in with natural comments but they got deleted
........so...... how is this different from what we have BEEN doing for the past year
Well those two threads had very little useful info compared to the general chat about anything and everything. Also, the idea here is to create separate threads, not just post in one thread.