I5 or AMD Phenom X6?

xaerux

Distinguished
Aug 19, 2010
3
0
18,510
Hello,
I am wondering which processor is better for serious gaming. I will not be doing SLI, I think.. Also, which one is better just all around..
 

aprillia99

Distinguished
Aug 19, 2010
35
0
18,530
well first off if u are considering dual video cards i would go with ATI, they're fail rate is much better then Nvidias right now and u normaly get more bang for th buck. but between the 2 cpu i would say the i5 might be a little bit better due to the hyperthread (creating virtual cores) they are not a powerful as real core but help out none the less, but normaly AMD is a bit cheaper. so i would go with AMD unless money isnt a prob then the i5, but honestly i dont think i will know the difference, as long as u have enough RAM and a good video card
 

rickzor

Distinguished
Feb 11, 2007
506
0
18,990


Hmm..do I5 have Hyperthreading?
 

scotu

Distinguished
Jul 19, 2010
102
0
18,710
The i5 will be a better gaming processor due to its better architecture and higher clock rate. Games don't take advantage of more than 4 cores, so an i5-750/760 is enough in terms of that (the Phenom II X6 will perform much better for heavy workloads such as video encoding). In Fact, the i5-750/760 is probably one of the best possible processors for gaming. If you were considering going the AMD platform route and don't need to do rendering/transcoding, then go with a Phenom II X4 instead of the X6.

Also, 2x GTX 460s are really good as far as 2 graphics cards go.
 

jj463rd

Distinguished
Apr 9, 2008
1,510
0
19,860
Gaming most likely the i5.Here is a benchmark comparison between the older i5 750 and the much more expensive Phenom II X6 1090T.You can find other benchmarks as well.
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/109?vs=146
There is a faster i5-760 available now too so it would bench higher than the 750.
I still haven't seen any benchmark for comparison for flight simulator X between these 2 CPU's so for that particular application it's still a mystery but FSX can effectively utilize 6 cores (rare) so it is possible that the 6 core AMD CPU actually might run better or that the benches on those 2 CPU's might be close.
I would say that all around you would be better off with the i5 preferably the 760.
 

BadTrip

Distinguished
Mar 9, 2006
1,699
0
19,810



There is no hyper-threading on i-750 or 760, but they are both great gaming CPUs.
 

Only the dual core i5 support it. the i5 quad does not have it. If it did, it would be an i7 :)

If you have no plans to use more than one video card, don't spend more than $160 on a CPU.

Unless "just all around" means something CPU intensive or something that can make use of 6 CPU cores.
 

TommyV

Distinguished
Aug 1, 2010
79
0
18,630



i5-760, 4 cores, no hyperthreading