Looks like the Asus P8Z68-V Pro is getting some early interest from the voters. I'm likely looking at that one too. It has 12+4 digitally-controlled phases, which appears important here, in part. The Asrock Z68 Extreme4 is enticing, and I would probably get an Asrock Z68 Extreme6 over an Asus P8Z68-V Pro were it available at launch, but that's not looking to be the case.
I've come across this really nice spreadsheet guide to the P67 boards:
https://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=0AoXai57oo6AGdGRrbG1feUNZODVGNmluTF9ZMHlDR0E&w=245&h=910
The Z68s that are the P67's counterparts look to be very similar and even slightly better.
Based on that and this 5 P67 board review and OC comparison, http://www.techspot.com/review/380-intel-p67-motherboard-roundup/page23.html, I'm thinking Asus has the goods for durability (a generous # of phases and digital electricity delivery monitoring/control) and overclockability. An Asus Z68 Deluxe board would likely be amazing, as well, but I haven't seen anything on the internet about it yet, and it's 1 week to the Z68 launch.
A word on Gigabyte's boards, their Z68s appear to be out in Asia already, but lacking on-board video ports and losing the P67 OC comparison with their flagship board to a mid-high Asus board, their high phase count appears underwhelming. Maybe the actual components aren't as good as what Asus uses, and/or is it the DIGI VRM that's got Asus the edge?