GPU Fan vs Heatsink (XFX 5870)

[underclocker]

Hi,
I'm planning to create an i7-930 build in a short while, and wondering which cooling method is better for an ATI HD 5870:

I want to know which one cools better and quieter. I don't plan to overclock, but buy another one when the price comes down (when 6xxx series comes out)

From what I have researched, The first one sounds like a jet engine, while the other one sounds like a loud fan.

Thanks for your help

 

[rolli59]

I belief the one with the bigger fan is quieter.

 

[OvrClkr]

Normally non-reference versions are more silent, but they also cost more.

 

[wa1]

I guess the 2nd option is better, it has a bigger fan...

 

[bystander]

One thing worth noting is that the non reference version is likely going to vent more air into the case. The fan is placed in the middle, which will push air out both sides of the card. It shouldn't be a problem if you have a good case and fan setup.

 

[Lmeow]

^+1, also the second version is cheaper, (does not come with backplate either) which may mean that the cooling system may be as sufficient and quieter, but will, as bystander said, vent more hot air into your case.

 

[underclocker]

Thanks for your help.

 

[jasongranholm]

Does anyone have a xfx 5870 xxx for sale? I really want to buy one and can't find one. Please email me if you do.
jasongranholm@hotmail.com