Tom's Hardware > Forum > Old Man/Woman's Club > Polls > world without money
Page:    Previous 1 2 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

From reading some scifi stories and just thinking about how stupid things are.

can you imagine a world without money?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

No way. People are inherently lazy. Its easier being greedy. So we automatically become greedy and self-centered unless we work hard to become caring and to some extent, selfless.

If money is removed from the equation, being greedy becomes much harder. So, not in a million years.

Unless of course, an alien race pops by and says,

<font color=purple>"eh. you guys are slobs. There is such a divide between your rich and your poor. You don't care, blah, blah blah

...


There is another evil alien that plans to destroy you. We'll let them, if you don't get your act together."</font color=purple>

Thats the only way, we'll rid ourselves from money. Actually it may be even harder. Our politicians, will insist we need money unless the alians specifically say lose your currency system.


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

"people are inherently lazy"
I think that is too broad a statement.
Some people I know are lazy but most of them are not.

About the future without money.
What if robots are created that can do almost everything we can now?
It is possible that the robots could do most of the work needed to live. Then people could be given more time on whatever we want.

Of course in our current system, if robots could do what we can then most companies would lay off all the human workers. Have robots do all the work. Then these same companies would wonder why nobody is buying their products.
Because we would be all out of work and would have no money :eek:
Bob

Reply to lisabob2

Don't get me wrong. Not, lazy as in I can't be bothered to do this, so I won't. More like, I don't want to this, I'm just doing it cos there are immediate concequences. Very few people do things because they actually deeply want to do it.

Being lazy does have its advantages though. It has been the primary reason for many great inventions. So we have to work less. Doesn't always work that way. nowadays, almost all inventions are for financial gain.

Also people block inventions and progress because it will result in financial loss. e.g. Oil companies, RIAA, MPAA etc.

There have been many issues in the past regarding advent of technology that replaces human labour. Many places the fears turned out to be false.

Assembly line workers getting replaced by robots, typing pools getting replaced by a small number of printers running from one or more computers etc.

In many places robots would be far more expensive than human. From a cost benifit point of view, I don't think any robot would be able to compete with the 10 year old kid in bangladesh putting together the next nike top or shoe earning 5 to 10p a day.

Robots are expensive because of the required initial investment followed by regular power-consumption and maintenance costs.

We live in a extreme capitalist world, where we apparantly need to have a million people dying of poverty in order to have a billionaire. Thats supposed to be right, and I don't see that changing in my lifetime, or the next few generations for that matter.


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

How do you reward people that work hard? I make a lot more than lazy coworkers and that's the way it should be. Should I work and get the same as my lazy coworkers?



_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

How about the people that work harder, but receive far less, if nothing at all?

I can, in a very very very far away future, forsee something else. Humanity is, after all, striving for perfection. If we ever reach it,(something I doubt very much) money will have no place there.

<b> A mosquito is just a small woodpecker. </b>

Reply to Snorkius

okay mising point, no money.
can we live without it?
Bob
"money is the root of all evil"

Reply to lisabob2

Can't live without some form of barter and exchange.

Salt, Coins, Notes & favours....it's all currency.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

Can you not imagine anything different??
I know what I am talking about cannot happen now but maybe in the future.
Can you imagine a world where robots do most or all of the work, everybody gets what they need, everybody is equal.
And you can pursue what you want to in your life.
I know fantasy but good fantasy. But banks will never let it happen
Bob

Reply to lisabob2

So basically Communism with robots providing the labour instead of humans.....

If you can genetically breed out the greed, jealousy and pride factors in humans, you may have a chance.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

Here's my fantasy.

A time in the future (hopefully in the next 10 minutes) a beautiful woman will come to my door, let herself in, cook my supper, perform unmentionable acts of supreme pleasure on me and then shove me in front of the football with a bottle of Whisky.

Just as unlikely as yours! :lol:

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

My god man, you're a bloody genius.

<font color=blue>"If you want the rainbow, you’ve gotta put up with the rain. Do you know which philosopher said that? Dolly Parton. And people say she’s just a big pair of tits.” - David Brent</font color=blue>

Reply to RobD

All hail Camie!

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

We have systems on Earth in which people are not rewarded more or less than those that work harder or less harder than them. It's called socialism and communism. Both systems suck. They breed stupidity and laziness. How many people on welfare do you know that are changing the world?

A world without money? How do you motivate people? A select few people have lived on this Earth and worked for it's greater good. You can probably count them on your fingers and toes. What about the other billions and billions of people?

People need to be told that they do a good job, they need to be patted on the back, they need to be given something that they can touch and feel in order to know that they did a good job. If you don't have money you're going to have to give them something else. What do you propose? The Star Trek system is about the only thing that I could imagine working but you would need a war of epic proportions in order to purge the greediest of man. What you're asking for is a revolution of mankind.

Getting rid of money is on par with getting rid of religion. Not everyone is willing or even capable of thinking deeper than what the bible or some preacher tells them and not everyone is willing to work their whole life without being rewarded more or less than the guy next to them.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Nah, getting rid of money is way harder than getting rid of religion. As far as humans are concerned that is.

<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

With 95% of the globe religious I beg to differ. I think they're pretty comparable. I at least couldn't imagine a world without money having religion. They both will have to go. Religion breeds ignorance and ignorant people will never give up money.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Ignorance will stay long after religion is abolished. Its just something people find easy to blame. Stops them from having to actually look for root causes.


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

religion breeds ignorance?????????? i take offence to that.

wpdclan.com cs game server - 69.12.5.119:27015

Reply to jihiggs

Sorry. I believe that to be true though.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Root causes of ignorance? Parents, teachers, and role models. Since religion is tied into all of those I think religion plays a big part. Of course getting rid of one won't get rid of the other.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Lets look at one of the things. When most of middle america says religion is bad, it mean to say islam is bad.

What is the main reason they hate islam? Al qaeeda.

Who created Al Qaeeda? Osama bin laden.

Why? because he was pissed that his partner in crimes, America, fu<ked hime and left him when she didn't need him anymore, and doesn't even call anymore.

So, what does he do? he starts taking action against his former partner out of spite. he needs people to do that.

How can he get people? Seems America is syphoning money out of many of the arab countries and giving money endlessly to israel. So, he uses that to recruit many of the people that feel the american actions are unjust. He brainwashes them into thinking they are doing deeds in the name of islam, and trains them as his soldier. And they do a pretty effective job.

True, religion is used in that context, but it is not the cause. Otherwise, athist people, wouldn't have crime. They wouldn't hate or despise. They would live in peace, love and harmony.

Yeah fu<king right.

<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

What are you talking about?

Islam? I'm not talking about one religion. I'm talking about all of them.

Scientology, Catholism, Christianity, 7th Day adventists, Islam, etc etc.

I don't see them doing us any good. I see them breeding ignorance.

The political situation is another situation all together. The violence is just a product of the ignorance.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Quote :

True, religion is used in that context, but it is not the cause. Otherwise, athist people, wouldn't have crime. They wouldn't hate or despise. They would live in peace, love and harmony.

Yeah fu<king right.




Who says that atheists have to be perfect? I'm saying that relgion is breeding ignornace.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

I'll start by saying that most people, including *you*, are ignorant. I would say I'm ignorant about a lot of things.

Ignorance is the refusal of people to think. You, IMO, don't think about a lot of the things you say. Most your political discussions, for example, are taken straight out of a propaganda text-book. You refuse to question the things your government and your leaders tell you. They are, <i>par defaut</i>, right. How is that any different to what you call religion?

I see religion as the refusal to admit that life is more than the physical, material world we live in. I refuse to believe that my life has no purpose. Religion is faith. How you express that faith is of far less importance.

I am Christian. I was born in a Christian country all my ancestors were Christians. I have no reason to question my fate. Especially since Christian doctrine makes a lot of sense if you don't take things at face value. You can't take things in the Bibel literally, that would be 'ignorant'. But most of the moral doctrine makes a lot of sense if you'd ever bothered to sit down and think things through.

So, after thinking long and hard about religion, faith and my place in the world, I have come a number of logical conclusions. How does that make me ignorant?


<b> A mosquito is just a small woodpecker. </b>

Reply to Snorkius

The fact that I see the world as a cup half full rather than half empty does not make me ignorant.

We can have different political opinions if they're based on fact and not be ignornant one way or the other.

I disagree with HG, Ksoth, and you on a number of political topics but I wouldn't say that any of us are ignorant for that reason.

Quote :

I am Christian. I was born in a Christian country all my ancestors were Christians. I have no reason to question my fate. Especially since Christian doctrine makes a lot of sense if you don't take things at face value. You can't take things in the Bibel literally, that would be 'ignorant'. But most of the moral doctrine makes a lot of sense if you'd ever bothered to sit down and think things through.



Do you mean that though? Saying that you don't take the bible at face value and then in the next breath declaring Anthropology, Physics, and Biology to be flawed sciences since they disagree with the story of the bible would be hypocritical. Please don't do that.

I learned morals and values from my family. I didn't need to go to church or read the bible. So what exactly is it that I missed? (FYI, I did read the bible. I read it in college for a mythology class. That's where it belongs, not as a teacher of morals and values)

I suppose I could let my life slip away and I could pick up on some of those wonderfull values such as repressing my natural desires and waiting to make love to the woman I love until after marraige. I suppose I could then bypass that by having anal sex with her like the Catholics do in Brazil. That's a shot at Scamtron of course, but there is so much in religion that bothers me including how I should live my life. Maybe I should adopt other religious moral values such as finding abortion to be a sin even though that child might have been the product of a horrible rape and isn't wanted. These are all mainstream religious values.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

I'm not big on sucking dicks... Do you have tities?

<b> A mosquito is just a small woodpecker. </b>

Reply to Snorkius

Look, all I'm saying is it's not religion or lack thereof that 'breeds' ignorance. Ignorance is inherent. We are born ignorant and we die ignorant. Real, certain, 100% knowlege is not possible during our life. Science is a religion like any other.


P.S. The Bibel was written by people far wiser than myself. It would pride and folly to think otherwise. If you don't take it literaly, as no one should, it does not contradict anything.

<b> A mosquito is just a small woodpecker. </b>

Reply to Snorkius

The bible is a story. It's a very good one though. There's a reason it's popular. People want to believe in it. They want to believe that they aren't insignificant specs of dust in a vast universe so large that the human mind can't even grasp it.

Nothing is 100% certain. However, the bible is not like science. Science is not a story. Science is based on fact. The bible is based on faith. My issue is when fact and faith are mixed. That's ignorant. Don't get me wrong though. Looking at science as fact forever is ignorant as well. Science is constantly changing as we find better ways to explain the universe.

I also don't believe that we are inherintly ignorant. However, if you're raised from birth, being told ignorant things, then odds are you will believe that. There is probably nothing that I can say that would make you believe that your precious bible is not perfect. In your mind it is a book of wisdom brought to us from God and it shares with all of mankind..yada yada yada. Even though you just said that we're all ignornant I doubt you'd be willing to admit that the bible was written by fallible ignorant men just like the ones that you think we are.

I get a kick out of this everytime. It's kinda like Paul didn't steal all the treasure that he collected for all those years. He lost it while crossing the desert. The records just stop mentioning all the money but no religious person would dare suggest that maybe he stole it. He couldn't possibly have been motivated by greed like the horrible men of today could he? He was surely so much wiser.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Parents, teachers and role models are root causes of ignorance?

If you listen to em more, you may find the opposite to be true. Without all of the above, how does one overcome ignorance?

Granted there are bad examples of all, but there are good ones too.

Religeon doesn't breed ignorance. A religeon's representatives may choose not to move forward with progress from time to time and be thought of being ignorant. If everyone was a devout practiser of a 'good' religeon, (one which practises peace) there would be next to no crime etc etc.

Or would there?

Wars based on religeon (or the excuse was always there) have been constant as far back as records show.

Religeon doesn't breed ignorance. It's the leaders of countries/religeon that allow ignorance to flourish that are to blame.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

When you are born you know nothing. Ergo, you are ignorant of <i> everything </i>. Simple as that.

The bible is not perfect. Everyone is fallible. <i>But</i> it has been a guide to a large part of humanity for thousands of years. I am not going to say that all those people through the ages were ignorant. We know no more than they did about the things that really matter. All our scientific 'facts' amount to nothing in human terms.

<b> A mosquito is just a small woodpecker. </b>

Reply to Snorkius

I'm sorry, but your notion of religion breeding ignorance simply does not stand. It makes no sense. I'm sure you care to back it up with specific examples.

Religion is just one of huge number of things people take advantages of to make their gains. But religion is one of a very few things people can turn to when things get tough.


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

Religion can be used as a tool to exert control over people. That's not a problem with religion, that's a problem with people.

Religion is an excuse for violence. Wars have been fought because people have different beliefs. Again, though, that is a problem with people, not with religion.

You blame all the world's woes on religion... yet you fail to realize what is at the root of religion... people. If people didn't have religion to excuse their actions, they would have something else. The other thing you fail to realize is that if everyone actually followed the precepts of their religion, we really would be better off. Peace, forgiveness, etc... all qualities we should strive for.

People will do what they do with or without religion. Just like money, it's a form of control over others.

<font color=red> If you design software that is fool-proof, only a fool will want to use it. </font color=red>

Reply to Zoron

I must say that all these posts since my last one made me think.

I agree with pretty much everything. Nonetheless, I honestly deep down believe that if we didn't have organized religion we would live in a better world.

I'm not an atheist or agnostic. I just don't subscribe to ORGANIZED religion. See where I draw the line?

Not moving foward and progressing, leaders and religious leaders taking advantage of their followers, people taking advantage of religion to make their gains, and/or using religion as a tool to control people have all been mentioned above. Everyone wants to excuse religion and blame the people, which would be nice, but in the end it was all done in the NAME of religion. I'm not very familiar with Asian religion, but as far as Western and Middle Eastern religion is concerned they can all go. They abuse people's faith in them.

People need to believe in a higher power, they need to believe that they aren't insignificant, they have to know that there is something greater out there. I understand that. What I don't understand is why one religion pits itself against another or why one religion is better than another. The similarities between most religions are almost exclusive. The differences insignificant. Yet organized religion breeds hate and a lack of understanding for fellow man even though they're nearly identical.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Quote :

But religion is one of a very few things people can turn to when things get tough.



I was raised to believe that if I ever need anything I turn to my family. My family has always been there for me. Whether I need support, money, or just someone to talk to I turn to my family. I would assume that the same is true for all of us. What is it that religion can provide that is above and beyond that?

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

And for those without family?

You still haven't given any specific examples where religion was the root cause of some evil or ignorance and such?


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

Friends. I knew someone would say that so I kept that in my bag of tricks :)

My friends have been there for me as well.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

And you think your friends can provide you with all the solace you will ever need?


Still no evidence from you of religion destroying humanity.

<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

My friends and family provide me with everything I need short of what a wife/girlfriend can provide.

Religion destroying humanity? I said it breeds hate and ignorance. Whether you choose to believe that it's the people or the religion, I say that the people are doing it in the name of religion and that's the same thing. Religion is nothing without the people so obviously the people are the ones responsable.

It doesn't have to be something as significant as the Taliban or Al Queda.

It could be something as stupid as a Jewish family who doesn't want their son or daughter marrying a non-Jew. It could be that poor Mormon family who couldn't pay their 15% fee to the church and were kicked out. It could be the fool who believes that the Earth is 7000 years old. It might be the guy who forces his daughter to give birth to a child concieved by rape. It could be forced female circumcision. It could be the refusal to use a condom.

All of it is ignorant, hatefull, useless, and common.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

I do have an answer for you but um... what the hell is female circumcision? :-p



<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

People don't need religion to be totally ignorant.

Learn the meaning of the word weltanschauung. It will answer many of your biases on this topic.

<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

There are a couple of different ways to do it I believe. One way is the removal of the labia and sewing shut the vagina. The husband is then supposed to pull the stitches out on her wedding night. It's a horribly disfiguring procedure.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Quote :

People don't need religion to be totally ignorant



I agree.

I think religion is contributing to ignorance though by instilling in people's minds ideas and values that are destructive. They are told things their whole lives under the geiss of religion that aren't exactly helpfull or healthy.

_________________________________________
<font color=red>12 bit... The way games are meant to be played!</font color=red>

Reply to dhlucke

Examples of religeon destroying humanity...

Lets see.....

Name any war in history and you'll see religeous implications. Usually their really political, but the masses fought for their religeon.

A little closer to today:-

Northern Ireland
Isreal
KKK
Taliban
Kosovo

and almost any other terrorist situation you can think of.

The misuse/misinterpretation of religeon is responsible for more death, hate and suffering than any other reason. 100 years ago it would have been,

"They want to kill us, so lets kill them."

Now it's,

"They can't kill us so leave them alone" - but terrorists won't sit back and do nothing like we will.



I don't blame religeon. I blame it's misuse.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

On a side note, have a good read of this site - <A HREF="http://www.human-net.org/war-issue/en/reag/rights.htm" target="_new">Linky</A>

Hindsight is 20/20 but it's a good way to see how some would try to motivate others, either because they fear the alternative or because they have been convinced that their truth is the real truth.

Famous saying time:-

A clever man only believes half of what he is told.

A wise man knows which half to believe.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz

Much of that is due to the politics surrounding religion, not because of religion itself.


<b><font color=red>"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."</font color=red><font color=blue> - Benjamin Franklin</font color=blue></b>

Reply to HolyGrenade

Quote :

what the hell is female circumcision?


You are better off not knowing. It is commonly done in the Middle East and Africa.

<font color=red><i>Doctor Hooter</i></font color=red> <A HREF="http://www.page3.com/" target="_new"><b>(·Y·)</b></A>

Reply to zpyrd

Exactly. The problem is, you will always have good people and bad people. You will always have good people who turn bad later. These people will take advantage of laws which we follow. They will take advantage of our good natures and use them to ill ends.

Trying to legislate humanity itself is pointless. We now have laws in this country preventing the legal use of handguns, but at the same time the lunatics are allowed out in the streets. Criminals are let out early. Honest, law abiding citizens are being caught by computers if they do a small amount of speed more than the legal limit.

So much effort in catching those who are basically good, and so little in keeping the bad citizens from doing exactly what they feel like.

What is going on???

Call it humanity, liberalism, being a good samaritan or whatever. Allowing legislation of this nature is crazy.

<b><font color=blue>~ <A HREF="http://forums.btvillarin.com/index.php?act=ST&f=41&t=324&s=58e94ba84a16bedfebbf0f416d5bac48" target="_new">System Specs</A> ~<font color=blue></b> :wink:

Reply to camieabz
Previous
1 2
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Old Man/Woman's Club > Polls > world without money
Go to:

There are 1174 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them