Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Closed

Touchscreen Computing: Gateway ZX4931 And HP TouchSmart 310

Last response: in Reviews comments
Share
May 12, 2011 4:31:23 AM

This article was worth what I can only assume was a torturous trip to Best Buy. But curiously, I'm not thinking about all in ones, but rather touch screens. Dell makes an eIPS panel with a touch screen for not a ridiculous sum of money. I've been considering it for a foray into touch screen computing on my desktop where I have the juice to do it right.

Toms strikes another blow against boring reviews. Good job.
Score
1
May 12, 2011 6:00:04 AM

Interesting subject - could this really be the computer's future? I don't think that the keypad will be replaced until voice control is more mature.
Score
0
Related resources
Anonymous
May 12, 2011 6:39:27 AM

Voice control is not the future; it's been around forever. Until computers can think, you can't talk to them.

In reference to the article, while desktop DIY rigs are definitely orientated to serve a central purpose, these all-in-ones are just as purpose built to serve an environment. (eg kitchen, living area)

Make touchscreens more seamless. By seamless I mean cheap. Where is the touch screen film I can just roll over whatever I want? How about a coffee table that recognizes my devices and my Heineken?
Score
-1
May 12, 2011 7:49:04 AM

Voice control has been around forever - duh. Brilliant observation. And while we are making observations, there is at least one computer you can talk to, IBM's Watson, which won jeopardy. Quality voice control is just coming into being.

What I meant was that until we have better voice control / input, a keypad will be necessary because typing on a vertical touchscreen, which is obviously awkward, would not suffice to do say a high school homework assignment.

Even with better voice input there may be some physical interface like a mouse. Right now cutting edge voice control for consumers is what we find with Ford's "Sync." But that would not work for a work station.

Touch screens like the Ipad have their strengths but nobody thinks they will replace computers with keyboards (nettops excepted).

However, if we have a "Watson" interface where we can provide input via voice control: that is the future of computers. With Watson you could virtually ask it to do any function, search any website or dictate a spreadsheet to it. Per your example, you could ask Watson to make your coffee and then put the morning newspaper on the built-in LCD coffee table viewer, turn the AC down to 75 degrees and find out what traffic is for the morning commute and it would be cable of doing all these things with voice input only. Bill Gates's home has many of these functions without an AI interface.
Score
2
Anonymous
May 12, 2011 11:53:24 AM

I hate touch screens, bringing it to the PC just annoys me, I dont want to touch my screen, do not see a use for it...

The next step forward is voice control that works!
Score
0
May 12, 2011 1:52:54 PM

This article is one of the worst I have ever seen on Toms Hardware. It seems rushed, is missing tons of relevant information, and basically skims over the most important features of a touchscreen computer.
Score
1
Anonymous
May 12, 2011 1:55:49 PM

On the HP display ... is it 20" and ??? as on the lead page or is it 23" and 1600x900 as on the Display Spec page ? Because HP says it's 20" and a 1080P display for the 310 series.
Score
0
May 12, 2011 3:45:43 PM

Touch screens on desktops are an ergonomical nightmare

Just point your finger at your display for a while. Your arm will start hurting after about 2 minutes.
Score
2
May 12, 2011 3:52:10 PM

MacTheKnifeOn the HP display ... is it 20" and ??? as on the lead page or is it 23" and 1600x900 as on the Display Spec page ? Because HP says it's 20" and a 1080P display for the 310 series.


Fixed!
Score
0
May 12, 2011 3:56:34 PM

cknobmanThis article is one of the worst I have ever seen on Toms Hardware. It seems rushed, is missing tons of relevant information, and basically skims over the most important features of a touchscreen computer.


If you want to see something specifically please let us know. If there is one thing missing, it's more discussion on software/touchscreen demos, but we provided these as videos. And, as this is Tom's Hardware not Tom's software, we wanted to focus on the hardware.
Score
0
May 12, 2011 3:58:59 PM

flong said:
Interesting subject - could this really be the computer's future? I don't think that the keypad will be replaced until voice control is more mature.


A cooler setup would be something ala Minority Report. Think of Kinect on steriods...
Score
0
May 12, 2011 4:06:35 PM

Tom's Hardware - don't listen to cknobman, this was a fascinating article and you guys do a great job with your reviews. I am not that interested in touch-screen computers and I enjoyed reading it.
Score
0
May 12, 2011 5:04:59 PM

flong said:
Tom's Hardware - don't listen to cknobman, this was a fascinating article and you guys do a great job with your reviews. I am not that interested in touch-screen computers and I enjoyed reading it.


Thanks for the kudos!
Score
0
May 12, 2011 6:54:12 PM

molo9000Touch screens on desktops are an ergonomical nightmareJust point your finger at your display for a while. Your arm will start hurting after about 2 minutes.


Yup, not to mention that with a 24" monitor I sit 4 foot from the screen and only have 2 foot 6 inch long arms...
Score
1
May 13, 2011 10:20:22 AM

ackuA cooler setup would be something ala Minority Report. Think of Kinect on steriods...

That is right. That is the future. Anything else will not make it to the times when brain-computer-interface will change forever the way we interact in full productive ways with the machines.
BCI + projected into the retina displays will be the step right before nanomachines will be able to hijack our I/O nervous system.

Exciting future is ahead. Keep healthy people or you risk not seeing it.
Score
0
Anonymous
June 21, 2011 5:41:16 PM

I would like if I could get it with out the 'touch' screen.
Score
0
Anonymous
July 4, 2011 5:38:16 PM

Why not cite an overall preference with details why?

My friend just bought a Gateway ZX4931 and is thrilled with it. It seems that the angle of the HP all-in-one is straight up. Wouldn't that be harder to look at over extended periods of time? Another thing is that the Gateway unit has a line of light under the display. I thought this would be an annoyance but it actually adds. There is no mention in your article. BTW, the Gateway display is fabulous. Is the HP equal? The Gateway has five USB slots in the back (as well as the two on the right side). This adds functionality, but it seems a hassle to go to the back of what is the unit's bulkiest part. No mention....

I never heard of Tom's Hardware, but I share the view that at least this comparison piece was superficial and weak. A real nuts and bolts value comparison between the two would have been "outtasight!" I don't see how your article as it is would aid a shopper interested in models made the ways these two are, especially a shopper who is not technically up on things. I didn't see the HP unit in action, so to speak, but I can say that the Gateway ZX4931 makes what I've been using seem like from another era!
Score
0
!