Presuming the polarity is the same, the specs are similar (12V at 2.0A). Most replacement Personel Storage 3100 OEM PSU replacement are 3.0A, but a few sites also sell a 2.0A unit; therefore I'll presume that 2.0A is enough.
As you can see, the Plextor PSU meets the requirements. Did that external drive work before or is it a unit that you got for free and hope to get working?