Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Other Components > [Solved] Are these computer specs good enough for avchd video editing in adobe premiere p

[Solved] Are these computer specs good enough for avchd video editing in adobe premiere p

Forum CPU & Components : Other Components [Solved] Are these computer specs good enough for avchd video editing in adobe premiere p

Best answer from LePhuronn.

Word :    Username :           
 

Hello,

I am upgrading my prosessor, graphics card and ram i use adobe after effects cs5 and and premiere pro cs5 to edit my avchd, so please tell me if you think these specks will be enough to edit avchd nice and smoothly?



Prosessor: Not sure beetween intel core i7 870 or i7 950????
Graphics Card: not sure beetween the NEW NVIDIA GEFORCE 9800GTX+ 9800 GTX+ 1GB GRAPHICS CARD

or

NEW NVIDIA GEFORCE GTX460 460 GTX 768MB GRAPHICS CARD
?????


Please answer

Reply to jacob1001
Register or log in to remove.

Processor isn't going to make too much of a difference if you use Premiere CS5 in hardware mode.

 

Personally I'd get a Core i5 760 and use the cash you save to get a 2GB GTX 460 from either Palit or Gainward, put in the CS5 CUDA hack and run everything in hardware mode.

 

Your edit will fly, and you won't be limited to AVCHD either.

 

As far as After Effects goes, the i5 760 has enough processing power to render things out in pretty quick time.

 

Just make sure you pair your i5 760 with 8GB RAM to give Dynamic Link some real stability (and with 4GB RAM modules finally showing up, see if you can stretch to 16GB RAM - CS5 will love you for it).


Message edited by LePhuronn on 10-29-2010 at 12:02:56 PM
Reply to LePhuronn

I thought the GTX465 was a better choice? Its the original Fermi chip that hasn't been scaled back. Its CUDA power is supposed to be better.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

Well my budget is $500 for an upgrade so i was quoted $250 to upgrade to 8gb of ram and on ebay 15 processors are $180 so that leaves me with buying windows 7 ultimate for $130 of ebay but i no not much about graphics card as cs5 was designed for nvidia graphics card i would need to no what to get for avchd video editing????

Reply to jacob1001

All i need to no is were i should start first by getting more ram, new procssor or new graphics card my current ram is 4gb (500gb).

Thanks
Jacob

Reply to jacob1001

jacob1001 wrote :

All i need to no is were i should start first by getting more ram, new procssor or new graphics card my current ram is 4gb (500gb).

Thanks
Jacob



What's your existing system then?

If you're looking at CPU upgrade you're gonna have to change your motherboard and probably your RAM too. So, you're looking at building a whole new system.

So after that, RAM will be the next choice, but if you're not already running DDR3, 8GB DDR2 can be a bit expensive.

So then it's the graphics card.

Oh, and don't bother with Windows 7 Ultimate - it costs a fortune and doesn't offer you anything of use over the Home version - save some cash and get Home.



@4745454b:
GTX 465 is knocked all over the park by the GTX 460 - Nvidia really messed up with it. The GTX 465 is a cut-down GF100 used in the GTX 470 and GTX 480, so it's hot, power-hungry and not much more powerful than the GTX 460.

The GTX 460 on the other hand is a nicely refined GF104 so it runs a lot cooler with less power draw, and certainly in games often matches or beats the GTX 465.

CUDA-wise, you see excellent Premiere CS5 acceleration from something as low as a 1GB GT 240, so I really wouldn't worry about the 16 less CUDA cores between the GTX 460 and GTX 465.

Reply to LePhuronn

Thank you am im just a bit confused about when u said changing my whole motherboard i thought it is easy as pulling the graphics card out and putting the new one in touching nothing else???

Reply to jacob1001

jacob1001 wrote :

Thank you am im just a bit confused about when u said changing my whole motherboard i thought it is easy as pulling the graphics card out and putting the new one in touching nothing else???



Not if you're changing processors - you said you're possibly looking at changing processor, so that will require a new motherboard and RAM.



What is your current system?

Reply to LePhuronn

Do you no how much that new motherboard would cost?

Reply to jacob1001

Have you been a member of this website for 40 years wow that alot!

Reply to jacob1001

jacob1001 wrote :

Do you no how much that new motherboard would cost?

 

It depends entirely on what CPU you want to get.

 


i7 870 will require socket 1156 motherboard, and they can be anything from $85 to over $300 depending on what you get.

 

i7 950 will require socket 1366 motherboard, which can be anything from $150 dollars and up.

 

On top of that, socket 1156 boards use dual-channel DDR3 RAM, socket 1366 boards use triple-channel RAM, which is a bit more expensive.

 


There is also the AMD route.

  

But, I'll ask again - what is your current system?????


Message edited by LePhuronn on 10-29-2010 at 01:27:08 PM
Reply to LePhuronn

You are so smart at computers,

am well my computer is at the shops right now getting repaired but i will tell you what i can remember it is but the information is on that computer.

Windows xp 2002 home edition
4gb of ram (500gb)
Graphics card - ?????Not sure will look tommorow
Processor??????
motherboard type???????????????????????

Reply to jacob1001

2x2GBs of DDR3 is anywhere from $75- $90 on newegg. x2 and you should be spending $150-180. I would never buy a MS OS used, nor off of ebay. You also don't need Ultimate. I'd be willing to bet Home Premium is enough for what you want to do. Lets say $170 for the ram, a $180 CPU and $100 for Win7 HP and your looking at $450ish spent so far. Here is where it gets tricky.

Its not that "cs5 was designed for nvidia graphics card" but cs5 can support running things with CUDA. Because of this you don't actually need a $180 CPU. You can buy a much cheaper CPU and spend the money on a video card which will be much faster then the CPU. You might want to look at a much weaker CPU ($80) then buy the Nvidia video card.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

ohk thanks for the reply well this might sound wierd but windows 7 ultimate is cheaper than home premium and professional as i am getting it offered to me at a discounted price $100 the full thing, i was thinking getting an i5 processor with and really good nivida graphics card and upgrading ram to 8gb????


What do u think?????????????????????????

Reply to jacob1001

I know of the differences between GF100 and GF104. I know 104 runs cooler, etc. There are more changes inside however other then the number of SP/CUDA cores. I don't have time to sort through it, but I'm talking about this stuff.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/3809 [...] 200-king/3

I'm not sure if the GTX465 or 460 is better at running this stuff.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

jacob1001 wrote :

ohk thanks for the reply well this might sound wierd but windows 7 ultimate is cheaper than home premium and professional as i am getting it offered to me at a discounted price $100 the full thing, i was thinking getting an i5 processor with and really good nivida graphics card and upgrading ram to 8gb????


What do u think?????????????????????????



By the sounds of it, going with an i5 CPU will require a new motherboard and new RAM so you're looking at a whole new system.


If I were you, I'd just upgrade your existing system to have 8GB RAM and get a decent Nvidia card - 2GB GTX 460 will be excellent for CS5 and gaming in one package.

And make sure you have a good power supply - 500W will be fine if you don't have one already.

Reply to LePhuronn

Thank you i found $290 for that card not sure if i should upgrade my processor or ram?????

Reply to jacob1001

Like I said, upgrading your processor will need a new motherboard AND new RAM, so it's a whole new machine.

But lots of RAM will really help out with your editing and graphics.


I think you're best off doing RAM and graphics card, but when your system comes back from repair let us know what your current processor is so we can give accurate advice.

Reply to LePhuronn

Ohk thanks ill get back to you tommorow dunno what country you are from but im from australia?

Reply to jacob1001

jacob1001 wrote :

What are your current computer specs?



Embarrassing atm :lol:


Still running with an old 3.2GHz Pentium 4 with 3GB RAM and GeForce 6800 Ultra, but she's tweaked to hell and back and still going strong.

Although I built my housemate a Phenom II X2 550 last Christmas for WoW and build all the systems for where I work.

I do have plans to build a new web server/file server/HTPC in the next month or so - Core i3 mini ITX system, and early next year my new workstation (for video, graphics and gaming) will be based off a i7 980X and Rampage III Extreme.

Reply to LePhuronn

Ohk my cousin has the best computer specs i have ever seen as he has the money to do all that ill tell you what he is currently running on.


Intel Core i7 980X Extreme Processor LGA1366 12MB
HP nVidia Quadro FX4800 1.5GB PCIe Graphics Card
13gb of ram

not sure the rest of the specs
he built it himself
its so fast


tell me what you think of his computer?

Reply to jacob1001
Best answer

Very nice system, although it's probably 12GB RAM, not 13 ;-)

He'll be using that for work then as the Quadro isn't a gaming card.

Reply to LePhuronn

yeh he has heavy work programs on his computer as he owns a apple packing factory and that computer controls the machines ect
i just need a little bit of help on my laptop i need to no if these specs are good enough for photoshop cs5


Manufacturer: Toshiba
Model: Notebook
Rating: 5.1 Windows experience index
Processor: Pentium (R) Dual-Core CPU T4400 @2.20GHz
2.20Ghz
Installed Ram (Ram): 4.00GB
System type: 64 Bit operating system
(What do you think of the computers system)????

Reply to jacob1001

Am the card that you reccomended me to get "GeForce GTX 460
" Specifications dont look that great ill send you the link to were i found it on ebay.
or maybe better you find a card on ebay and send me the link?????


http://cgi.ebay.com.au/NEW-NVIDIA- [...] 1e5f5c3990

Reply to jacob1001

Its come down to these three cards????

Nividia Geforce GTX465 - http://cgi.ebay.com.au/ECS-GeForce [...] 45f669a078

Nividia Gefore GTX460

and

ECS Nvidia Geforce GTS 250 2GB PCI-E 2.0 Video Card - http://cgi.ebay.com.au/ECS-Nvidia- [...] 20b32980e2



Which one do you reccomend????????????????????????

Reply to jacob1001

This topic has been closed by Mousemonkey

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Other Components > [Solved] Are these computer specs good enough for avchd video editing in adobe premiere p
Go to:

There are 2106 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Case with filters. Recommendations?
By al360ex, 6 hours ago:

Then I'd go with one of these cases. If you choose the HAF 932 Advanced Edition, you...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts