GTX460 768MB, 1GB or 5830 for 1920x1080 (Budget)

Hi! I would just like to know which from the GTX460 768MB, 1GB and the Radeon 5830 I should choose for a Radeon 4830 upgrade. I will be changing my monitor soon for a 1920x1080 23.6 inches LCD instead of my 1360x768 18.5 inches Samsung Syncmaster and I know my current graphics card won't handle it. I will also change my power supply in the next week for a Corsair TX750 unit.

My computer: AMD Phenom II x4 processor, Gigabyte GA-MA770T-UD3P motherboard, 4GB 1333MHz DDR3 memory, will upgrade my power supply for Corsair TX750, will change my monitor for ASUS 23.6 inches monitor.

I would like to have the most performance to play actual games maxed out for the best price. Some reviews on the net say that the 1GB is better for the price than the 768MB while others say that the 30$ difference is too big compared to the performance increases. I saw somewhere too that the price of the Radeon 5830 would be dropping to $170-180, so I don't really know what to do. Do I buy the GTX460 768MB or 1GB right now or wait for price drops and get the 5830.

If I take the GTX460 1GB, the cheapest one at the moment is the Palit Sonic version. I know that it is making a bit of controversy because of its missing VRM heatsink on the retail version, but when I look at the pictures of MSI's Cyclone GTX460 1GB, I doesn't have one too and reviews tell it runs cool. I think people are going crazy about the VRM heatsink for nothing since it has a warranty if it fails because of that.

If I go with the 768 MB version, should I take Evga's Superclocked edition or a stock one and overclock it myself? Do the Superclocked version overclocks better or it is just something to bait people who don't know how easy it is to overclock a video card a little?

If I choose the Radeon 5830, I would definitely go with Gigabyte's model. It has a nice heatsink with many heatpipes and 2 fans for great cooling. It can probably support a massive overclock.

I would like also to overclock the card I will buy to get the most out of it.

I will probably buy my graphics card in the next 6 weeks.

Thank you!
33 answers Last reply
More about gtx460 768mb 5830 1920x1080 budget
  1. the GTX 460 768mb is a better card then the ATI 5830, so the question is which GTX460 should you get; the 765mb or 1GB?

    I have the cyclone, it runs very cool.
  2. The 1GB is deffinitely worth the 30 extra dollars especially at the resolution you will be playing at.
  3. Ok then. I think I will wait for ATI - Nvidia price war though. Maybe they will lower the price on all the cards I mentioned. ^^
  4. GTX 460 1gb > GTX 460 786mb > HD5830
    I wouldn't count on the prices of any of them getting much lower any time soon.
  5. Ok, so this mornig I looked at the price of the Radeon 5830's. HIS iCooler V have passed from around $230 to $200 + $15 MIR. It's getting more and more interesting. ^^
  6. ibanez1337 said:
    Ok then. I think I will wait for ATI - Nvidia price war though. Maybe they will lower the price on all the cards I mentioned. ^^


    the GTX460 just launched, prices won't drop since the card is getting rave reviews. if anything they may go up because of the demand (similar to the ATI 5850 when it launched)

    even if ATI drops prices on the 5830, it still trails the GTX460 in performance. Plus they can only drop prices so far. The 5770 ranges from $160-180. The 5750 goes from $125-150, it not as simple as just dropping the price of one card.
  7. Diamond 5830 @ Fry's - $240 w/$20 rebate. Limit 1, but who cares. Have a friend (or trustworthy relative) help with the 2nd rebate if you need 2.
    http://www.frys.com/product/6229240?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG

    Also, it looks like Sparkre got on the 1GB-bandwagon for $220 - but I wouldn't expect their model to have a voltage regulator like MSI or ASUS:
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814187113


    As for me, my Diamond 5770 is going back to the store right now; GL!
  8. ct1615 said:
    the GTX460 just launched, prices won't drop since the card is getting rave reviews. if anything they may go up because of the demand (similar to the ATI 5850 when it launched)

    even if ATI drops prices on the 5830, it still trails the GTX460 in performance. Plus they can only drop prices so far. The 5770 ranges from $160-180. The 5750 goes from $125-150, it not as simple as just dropping the price of one card.


    +1, just get the 460 now.
  9. Quote:
    Asus or EVGA. Palit is ***


    my MSI cyclone kicks ass :kaola:
  10. EVGA GTX 460 1GB
  11. Hey guys. The EVGA GTX460 1GB just became available today on newegg.ca and it would cost $260 (CAD) with shipping and taxes. I think that's a bit too much for me, so do you think the 768mb overclocked at its maximum could do well at a resolution of 1920x1080?
  12. the 768 seems to be perfect for 1680x1050.

    here's the the OC evga 768 on 1080p
    http://www.kitguru.net/components/graphic-cards/zardon/evga-gtx-460-768mb-superclocked-review/9/
  13. Yeah, the 768mb should be fine. SLIing in the future is the main reason to go for the 1gb card imo but if that isn't in your plans then it isn't a big deal.
    As for which card to get I would go for the Asus one. Anyone know if the EVGA cards allow for voltage increases?
  14. Even if you do not plan to do SLI the 1 GB GTX 460 is a better long term solution.
  15. Two MSI cyclone 1 GB cards...if you can wait a week or two (until they are available), not too many doubts on this choice...5830 doesn't even come close.
  16. Tamz_msc said:
    Even if you do not plan to do SLI the 1 GB GTX 460 is a better long term solution.

    So would a GTX 470, 480, HD5970, ect... not sure what your point is.
  17. jyjjy said:
    So would a GTX 470, 480, HD5970, ect... not sure what your point is.

    I meant a better long term solution with respect to newer games using more memory at higher resolutions as well as the price he is willing to pay currently for the card.
  18. There is real nice super clocked 460 probably coming soon. I head of one with near 800Mhz preoverclock which will go for only like $250 and it was as fast as 5850. May be wait 1-2 weeks and then decide
  19. Tamz_msc said:
    I meant a better long term solution with respect to newer games using more memory at higher resolutions as well as the price he is willing to pay currently for the card.

    Of course more memory is better but it is only better in so far as it makes the card perform better. The bottom line is always performance and the two versions of the GTX 460 are appropriately priced for their relative performance(if anything the 768mb card is a slightly better deal.) I highly doubt the performance differential of the two cards will change all that much in the future.
  20. rawsteel said:
    There is real nice super clocked 460 probably coming soon. I head of one with near 800Mhz preoverclock which will go for only like $250 and it was as fast as 5850. May be wait 1-2 weeks and then decide

    Why would you pay for someone else to overclock your video card for you? You can undoubtedly achieve much better results easily on your own.
  21. jyjjy said:
    Of course more memory is better but it is only better in so far as it makes the card perform better. The bottom line is always performance and the two versions of the GTX 460 are appropriately priced for their relative performance(if anything the 768mb card is a slightly better deal.) I highly doubt the performance differential of the two cards will change all that much in the future.

    You do get noticeable performance increase withe the 1GB especially at 1920x1200.Games such as Metro 2033 will benefit from the 1 GB framebuffer. The price difference is only 30$ as well.
  22. The overall performance difference between the two cards is approximately 8% at 1920x1200 while the price difference is 15%. They are both good values for the money like I said. The extra memory and bandwidth is nice but it simply isn't that big of a deal.
  23. Its really up to the customer to get the best deal for the card.
  24. The consumer can't make deals that don't exist. For the GTX 460 right now 768mb/192 = $200, 1gb/256 = $230.
  25. rawsteel said:
    There is real nice super clocked 460 probably coming soon. I head of one with near 800Mhz preoverclock which will go for only like $250 and it was as fast as 5850. May be wait 1-2 weeks and then decide


    all the stock GTX 460 hit 800mhz at default voltage settings
  26. jyjjy said:
    Why would you pay for someone else to overclock your video card for you? You can undoubtedly achieve much better results easily on your own.


    agreed. My cyclone is factory OC but I got it for the cooler, not the factory OC.

    BTW, the cyclone cooler is by far the best one I have ever had on a video card and I have owned a good number of cards.
  27. I'd go with a 1GB GTX 460 myself. No point in getting the lesser RAM version in my mind, considering you want to play at 1920x1080. Higher RAM means larger textures. I wouldn't cripple the card by going 768MB, as future game titles may desire the extra RAM.

    As far as brands go. I've had several MSI video cards and never had a problem. :)
  28. jyjjy said:
    GTX 460 1gb > GTX 460 786mb > HD5830
    I wouldn't count on the prices of any of them getting much lower any time soon.


    are you freakin kidding me? you must not know atis line of video cards
  29. I'm very aware of their cards. Perhaps you are unfamiliar with the GTX 460? It did just come out. Check out some reviews.
  30. gamerdude72 said:
    are you freakin kidding me? you must not know atis line of video cards


    actually with that response, I would question your knowledge of ATI's line of cards and their performance. Every review has the GTX460 768mb faster then the ATI 5830.
  31. is there any reviews on Tom's with the 768mb vs. the 1gb version of the gtx460? (or on another site that u trust?)
    cause u quoted 8% difference with one card, but if the OP decides to SLi later on, what does the performance do then?
  32. ^^Here you go...
    http://www.guru3d.com/article/geforce-gtx-460-review/1

    I would say the 1GB. Coz it would definitely help in the higher resolutions!
  33. For SLI I would recommend the 1gb card.
Ask a new question

Read More

Graphics Cards Graphics Product