Try connecting the two on another branch of the wiring.
Trying to see if they connect at a faster speed.
Sounds like a wiring problem.
Thanks! It did turn out to be a wiring issue. The other branches of the network all connect at 1000mbps. I had tested the other branches with a laptop, but I never used the switch to run the wiring tests. The switch connects just fine everywhere but where I really need it to... I will have to look into running a new cable.