[Graphics Cards] To upgrade or not?

Ok so I recently rebuilt with a i5 760 Quad 2.8Ghz, 8Gigs A-Data DDR31600 and MSI P55A-GD65 motherboard. Other components are Corsair 850TX PSU, Antec900 Case, BFG GTX275 OC 896Meg GDDR3, dual Samsung 2333SW Monitors, dual Samsung DvDRW and (2) 250Gig HD one WD other is seagate.

Now with all the rebuilding I have done kinda got the itch to put a new video card in. The MSI will support Xfire (newegg shows SLI/Xfire however MSI site shows only Xfire), so if I go dual cards has to be ATI. I multitask alot, usually on a given day I can have 2 games, browser with 6-10tabs, voice comm, and more running. The game I play that probably is the heaviest on my graphics is CoDMW2 and/or Battlefield Bad Company 2.

The best I can find is that a single 5770 is about equal to what I have now, so in theory if I run dual 5770's in Xfire shouldn't it be better? Or would I be better served with a beefier single card such as a GTX470 or a HD 5870? I play WoW, CSS, MW2, BFBC2, UT2004 as well I use photoshop and Illustrator alot as well.

Thanks for any input, looking to purchase in the next 2 weeks budget is between $400-$500.

Here is the 5770 I have been looking at: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127490
Link to my Motherboard's product page: http://us.msi.com/index.php?func=prodmbspec&maincat_no=1&cat2_no=170&cat3_no=&prod_no=1999#menu
Link to current Video Card specs: http://www.bfgtech.com/bfgegtx275896ocxe.aspx
19 answers Last reply
More about graphics cards upgrade
  1. what resolution is your monitor?
  2. Dude, if you have that much money to spend you don't dicker around with 2 low end cards you get one high end card. There will be no comparison. Two low end cards may have the same or near same FPS numbers but the real performance will NOT be there. Especially when the game you play doesn't cross fire well.

    Using your card vs the 5770......... takes in point what I just said. If it were better performance i was looking for vs FPS the 275 or a 4870/90 1gig would be my choice of card over the 5770. Don't crap on yourself.
  3. 1920x1080 sorry forgot to include that.
  4. For $510 you can get two of these now;
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814150494
    Do it before the promo code expires.
  5. jyjjy said:
    I would go for a GTX 470.


    Agreed.
  6. lol
    You agree then I change my mind and edit right after :p
    Actually the GTX 470 should be more than enough for 1080p, especially if you overclock but two HD5850s would be the best you can do for the budget you have set.
  7. Yeah I was thinking a 470 should be enough for him, at 1080p as well.
    The Crossfire choice isn't bad either, it will deffinitly last longer and does fit in his budget.
  8. This card looks promising if I am going to stay with a single card that is.

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130549
  9. Don't pay for someone else to overclock your video card, it is just a waste of money. It is very easy to do on your own and you will get much better results.
    If you are going to pay that much get the Twin Frozr card for the best cooling;
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/ComboDealDetails.aspx?ItemList=Combo.455050
    Free Just Cause 2 and Mafia 2 is sweet as well.
  10. I'd recommend a single 5870. It will kick the 470 in the nuts and still play a good game(MW2) at the same time. Thats the good thing about ATi's. Multi-tasking :)

    Heres a 5870, Costs 399.99 but is a reliable brand and include Modern Warfare 2
  11. That HD5870 costs $400, not $300. In general the card isn't nearly worth the price difference compared to the HD5850 or GTX 470 IMO. When overclocking is taken into account the difference in performance tends to shrink down to almost nothing.
  12. True, However as the 5870 is generally cooler, and use's less power theres those factors to consider, extra power used = extra money spent in the long run.
  13. Not compared to the HD5850. They are the same processor, the HD5850 just has 10% of its shaders disabled and a lower stock speed. If seen benchmarks of both with a maxed out OC(around 1ghz) and the actual performance difference is about 7-8% on average which just isn't worth an extra $100 imo.
    As for the power difference with the GTX 470 it is overstated I think. Compared to the HD5870 it uses 10w more at idle and 30w more under load which isn't that big of a deal.
  14. Where I live, we worked this out in another thread, it only costs 15 dollars more a year to run a 5850 than a GTX 470.

    So by the time that factored in I would be replacing the cards.

    AMW1011 said:
    http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/nvidiageforcegtx480launch_032610115215/22208.png

    http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/nvidiageforcegtx480launch_032610115215/22204.png

    Comparing a GTX 470 and a 5850.
    -Idle delta: 10w
    -Load delta: 89w

    cents/kw-hr average: 20 (terrible electric prices in the US)

    4 hours a day of gaming = 1460 hours a year
    12 hours of idle = 4380

    Gaming = $25.99 extra.
    Idle = $8.76 extra.

    Combined price extra at TERRIBLE rates? $34.75 a year.

    http://www.handymath.com/cgi-bin/electric.cgi

    http://img294.imageshack.us/img294/9231/gaming.png

    http://img251.imageshack.us/img251/9987/gaming2.png


    http://www.eia.doe.gov/electricity/epm/table5_6_b.html

    Ok so I live in Indiana, at 8.95 (if I'm reading this chart right). So for me the difference between a 470 and 5850 would be roughly ~15.00 a year?

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  15. Keeping in mind that if the OC'ing screws up he could lose his warranty and lose alot more than $100 (-$15 for power)
  16. Helltech said:
    Where I live, we worked this out in another thread, it only costs 15 dollars more a year to run a 5850 than a GTX 470.

    So by the time that factored in I would be replacing the cards.


    http://www.eia.doe.gov/electricity/epm/table5_6_b.html

    Ok so I live in Indiana, at 8.95 (if I'm reading this chart right). So for me the difference between a 470 and 5850 would be roughly ~15.00 a year?

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    u meant its cheaper to run a 5850 then a gtx470 right?
  17. I prefer to not overclock my Video card myself, I am not a huge Overclocking fan as it I am working on getting my RAM to 1600 speeds cause my motherboard is only showing it at 1333 but I will deal with that when I have time.

    Another small note, my board is shown to be SLI/Xfire compatible on many sites just not on the MSI one, I will be emailing them to find out cause that will play a factor if I do get two cards.
  18. Just read the review on this card here and its looking very nice as an option for what I want.

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814125338
  19. decode said:
    Keeping in mind that if the OC'ing screws up he could lose his warranty and lose alot more than $100 (-$15 for power)

    As I have stated the HD5870 and HD5850 are the same exact processor, as are the GTX 470 and GTX 480. The higher stock clocks of the HD5870 and GTX 480 amount to essentially a factory overclock. There is NOTHING whatsoever that is dangerous about putting the HD5850 up to HD5870 speeds or a GTX 470 up to GTX 480 speeds. If you think that then you think the HD5870 and GTX 480 have dangerously high speeds at stock. The processors in these cards(and CPUs) have certain abilities and tolerances. The only thing one accomplishes by not overclocking them, at least to a mild degree, is having a pointlessly slower video card. Where the stock clocks were set for these cards is nothing more than a marketing decision.
    As for voiding a warranty some brands allow for overclocking and none of them could possibly know you did so unless you specifically go out of your way to tell them.
Ask a new question

Read More

Graphics Cards Graphics Product