Help me decide what MoBo to get

siberian

October 23, 2010 3:18:36 PM

Hi guys, need help deciding which one to get with these 3 Mobos:

ASUS M4A89TD PRO/USB3 AM3 AMD 890FX
MSI 890FXA-GD70 AM3 AMD 890FX
ASRock 890FX Deluxe4 AM3 AMD 890FX

As you can see all of it is a 890FX chipset, but i dont know which one will be better with my chosen specs:

Phenom II X4 965 (3.4G) 8mb black ed
Kingston 2GB 1333 MHz DDR3 x 2
WDC Blue 500GB
FSP Epsilon 600w 80+
MSI NVIDIA GeForce GTX 460
AeroCool VS-9

If you have some advice with the other parts let me know. Thanks :ange:

More about : decide mobo

| E-mail me updates
| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 23, 2010 3:31:02 PM

The MSI and Asrock boards have better voltage regulation, you can tell by the 8 pin cpu power plug, as opposed to the 4 pin on the Asus.

Asus should have an eight phase or better board as well, but you will have to pay for it.

Out of the three on you list I would choose the MSI board.

All that said, I would grab this board over all three

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E168...

| Report abuse

BenHarper87

October 23, 2010 4:09:24 PM

How important is voltage regulation? I've never come across it before!

| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 23, 2010 4:37:19 PM

It's more important if your going to overclock, but it helps when your not as well.

Better voltage regulation means you can set lower voltage values in bios. Effectively lowering heat and your electric bill.

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 5:17:01 PM

read this http://www.anandtech.com/show/3877/asrock-890fx-deluxe-... get an x6 and OC it, if you are not overclocking dont get an 890fx board its a bit of a waste

| Report abuse

Timop

October 23, 2010 5:22:28 PM

870FX boards are pointless for you, especially with a GTX460. Since you cant SLI anyways, you're paying more for a name.

I would suggest a HD6850/70 with the ASrock 870 Extreme3, you get better performance, room for expansion, great crossfire scaling if you plan to for less.

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 5:28:38 PM

Timop said:

870FX boards are pointless for you, especially with a GTX460. Since you cant SLI anyways, you're paying more for a name.

I would suggest a HD6850/70 with the ASrock 870 Extreme3, you get better performance, room for expansion, great crossfire scaling if you plan to for less.

agree with you 100% i didnt see that he was getting a gtx 460, the ATI 6xxx series is a better choice a 6870 is better than a gtx 460 1gb by quite a bit and the 6850 fits right in between the gtx 460 786mb and the gtx 460 1gb , and of course you cant SLI on an amd board

| Report abuse

Timop

October 23, 2010 5:31:43 PM

gordon_81 said:

agree with you 100% i didnt see that he was getting a gtx 460, the ATI 6xxx series is a better choice a 6870 is better than a gtx 460 1gb by quite a bit and the 6850 fits right in between the gtx 460 786mb and the gtx 460 1gb

Don't know what reviews you've been reading, but the 6850 is actually slightly better than the 460 1GB in most games (Obviously excluding Farcry2, and JustCause2), while the 6870 is more or less on par with the GTX470.

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 7:31:18 PM

The radeon hd 6850 should slide in ahead of the Radeon HD 5830 for $180 or so. that was quoted from the toms hardware review. 5830 vs gtx 460 786 mb http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/156?vs=171 assuming the 6850 is a bit better than the 5830 it should slot in between the gtx 460 786mb and the gtx 460 1gb

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 7:34:49 PM

also from the toms review "the radeon hd 6870 promises Radeon HD 5850-class performance at roughly $240."

| Report abuse

Timop

October 23, 2010 7:49:38 PM

gordon_81 said:

The radeon hd 6850 should slide in ahead of the Radeon HD 5830 for $180 or so. that was quoted from the toms hardware review. 5830 vs gtx 460 786 mb http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/156?vs=171 assuming the 6850 is a bit better than the 5830 it should slot in between the gtx 460 786mb and the gtx 460 1gb

Well, heres the numbers from TPU's review. http://tpucdn.com/reviews/HIS/Radeon_HD_6850/images/per...

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 8:15:06 PM

| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 23, 2010 8:35:04 PM

I'm sure the 6850 uses less power than the gtx 460 as well, correct me if I'm wrong

| Report abuse

gordon_81

October 23, 2010 8:45:14 PM

sportsfanboy said:

I'm sure the 6850 uses less power than the gtx 460 as well, correct me if I'm wrong

you are right, im not saying the 6850 is a bad buy, im just saying according to the toms hardware benchmarks the gtx 460 1gb is better, if i was buying i would get the 6850 over the gtx 460 1gb though, apparently crossfires scaling has improved quite a bit, 2 6870s are on par with 2 5870s

| Report abuse

Timop

October 23, 2010 9:09:16 PM

gordon_81 said:

Did you just read how the cards are ordered and not see anything about the actual fps?

In 3 of the 6 benchmarks you linked, the 6850 out performed the GTX460 1GB while on the other 2, the 6850 won as you upped the resolution. Only in JC2, a very Nvidia-biased game (Hence its bundled with GTX460s at launch), the 6850 loses by a small margin.

| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 23, 2010 9:35:00 PM

I really don't like the naming scheme. It should be the 6750

| Report abuse

siberian

October 24, 2010 6:06:24 AM

Timop said:

870FX boards are pointless for you, especially with a GTX460. Since you cant SLI anyways, you're paying more for a name.

I would suggest a HD6850/70 with the ASrock 870 Extreme3, you get better performance, room for expansion, great crossfire scaling if you plan to for less.

How about ASRock 880G EXTREME3 is it better? If not, is there any Mobos other than ASrock 870 Extreme3 that would you say equal or slightly better like MSI mobos? or Asus perhaps? :ange:

And for the GPU, XFX HD-685X-ZNFC Radeon HD 6850 or SAPPHIRE 100315L Radeon HD 6850? Which one has your vote?

| Report abuse

siberian

October 24, 2010 2:18:09 PM

Thanks Timop, I think im going for ASRock 890GX Extreme3, im also considering crossfire as soon as i get my 2nd GPU

| Report abuse

siberian

October 24, 2010 2:23:01 PM

Best answer selected by siberian.

| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 24, 2010 2:30:35 PM

The extra 20 dollars on the xfx is probably for the 2x life time warranty. That way you can sell the card with a lifetime left on it.

| Report abuse

Timop

October 24, 2010 2:34:56 PM

sportsfanboy said:

The extra 20 dollars on the xfx is probably for the 2x life time warranty. That way you can sell the card with a lifetime left on it.

Lifetime warranty should be a plus, not a feature you pay for.
Also, after 2/3 years, the cards wont be worth much anymore, so I wouldnet say the XFX is a good deal.

However, since the Sapphire is sold-out too, wait for the Gigabyte instead, the windforce cooler is decent.

| Report abuse

sportsfanboy

October 24, 2010 2:46:52 PM

It's a "Double life time" warranty, XFX is the only country that I know of that does that. It has it's uses if your the type that upgrades every year or so.

| Report abuse