Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphics & Displays > Graphics Cards > GTX 460 roundup - your pick

GTX 460 roundup - your pick

Forum Graphics & Displays : Graphics Cards GTX 460 roundup - your pick

Word :    Username :           
 
- 0 +

I've decided on a GTX 460 for my new build - please leave competing cards out of this thread for another discussion :non:

Anyway, I'm trying to choose the best option - been reading the roundup toms' did the other day

http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] ,2714.html

I plan on adding another for SLI later, prob in about a year. I DO plan on overclocking this card, though I haven't before and I'm learning.

Currently I'm looking at the MSI 1gb cyclone
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127510

It looks like a good option and I love the Seasonic X750 PSU combo.

Could anyone add any input on this variation of the card and/or others?

Reply to muckle
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

I take no pride in bumping, but tryin to make a decision here and I'd really like some input from some people who either own a 460 or are knowledgeable on the different options...

Reply to muckle
- 0 +

The Cyclone is one of the best GTX 460s and a good choice. The PSU is a bit pricey imo even with the combo but it is certainly a quality unit. Personally I would probably grab this;
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817207003
and then get the card with the free game(it's a good one);
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.455033
FYI the XFX PSUs are also made by Seasonic. The above is about $50 less after rebates. If you aren't interested in the game you can probably ebay it for an even larger price difference.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by jyjjy on 09-07-2010 at 05:55:30 PM
Reply to jyjjy
- 0 +

When it comes to NVidia cards the two best out there in my opinion are MSI (my last three cards were MSI - 6800GT, FX5900XT, and FX5200) and XFX. MSI has had incredible reliability but XFX is probably a bit better becasue of the lifetime warranty.

------------------------------ Intel Core i7-920@2.66GHz | Asus Rampage II Extreme | 2xSapphire ATI Radeon HD 5850 | 6X2GB Mushkin 9-9-9-24@1600MHz | 2xWD Velociraptor 300GB (Raid 0) & 2xWD Green 2TB (Raid 1) | Corsair TX950 psu | Cooler Master 690 II Advanced | Windows 7 Pro 64Bit
Reply to deweycd

muckle wrote :

I take no pride in bumping


Do it again and I'll close the thread. :non:

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
- 0 +

jyjjy wrote :

The Cyclone is one of the best GTX 460s and a good choice. The PSU is a bit pricey imo even with the combo but it is certainly a quality unit. Personally I would probably grab this;
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817207003
and then get the card with the free game(it's a good one);
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.455033
FYI the XFX PSUs are also made by Seasonic. The above is about $50 less after rebates. If you aren't interested in the game you can probably ebay it for an even larger price difference.



Excellent suggestion. That PSU is in a case combo I'll get that'll save me money.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.492896

And as long as it suits me for SLI and my needs it's perfect... plus I still get that free game.

Reply to muckle

My vote is definitely in favor of MSI's Cyclone 1GB GTX 460. It has always reviewed very well, and if I were going to put a GTX 460 in a machine that would be my most likely choice.

 

I've owned at least 3 MSI nVidia based video cards and never had a lick of trouble with them. The Cyclone 1GB GTX 460 has been stellar in every online review I've seen. Yet to hear anyone gripe about it. :) They seem to cool very well, which should give you optimal ability to OC.

 

BTW: EVGA is giving away a free Download of Metro 2033 if you buy a GTX 460 from them. So if you want that game, that might save cash. And the EVGA cards perform and I hear cool fairly well. However, I bought Metro 2033 and played it once through. Graphically it was fantastic. However, I have no desire to play it again. It's very linear game play, with no real plot line choices. And quite frankly, the guns in the game just really made me mad the whole way through. Shooting something with 20-50 rounds before it dies gets old after a while. ;)


Message edited by jerreece on 09-07-2010 at 08:33:03 PM
------------------------------ i5-750 4Ghz @ 1.32V / Gigabyte GA-P55-UD4P / Xigmatek HDT-S1283
GTX 470 SLI / 8GB GSkill DDR3 1600 9-9-9-24 @1.5v
2 x WD Caviar Black 1TB / Thermaltake Armor BWS8003
Win 7 64bit / Antec TPQ-850 / Vantage P31806 / 3dMark06 25351 / 3dMark11 P7597
Reply to jerreece
- 0 +

Mousemonkey wrote :

Do it again and I'll close the thread. :non:

 

What your not allowed to bump? He didn't get a single answer to an easy question in about an hour and a half, I can't blame him. Its actually kind of sad that he needed to.

 

To the OP:

 

The MSI Hawk is the best, if you can afford it, followed by the Cyclone.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by AMW1011 on 09-07-2010 at 09:46:08 PM
------------------------------ Want Rock and Metal?

Paul Online Radio Network: http://www.paulradio.net/
Reply to AMW1011

AMW1011 wrote :

What your not allowed to bump? He didn't get a single answer to an easy question in about an hour and a half, I can't blame him. Its actually kind of sad that he needed to.


Try reading the sticky, you know the one titled "Read this first" that no one bothers to read at all.

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
- 0 +

Mousemonkey wrote :

Try reading the sticky, you know the one titled "Read this first" that no one bothers to read at all.



Oh I have. However, is a single bump really worth the time? I guess that is my question. I'm not saying a disagree with rules, if that rule wasn't there it would be pretty chaotic. I'm just wondering if there is some flexibility to that rule. To me he had a pretty decent reason to bump.

No bumping and no number calling, I know.

Also MM, do note that I really value your contribution to the forums, you are a great and dedicated mod.

------------------------------ Want Rock and Metal?

Paul Online Radio Network: http://www.paulradio.net/
Reply to AMW1011

AMW1011 wrote :

Oh I have. However, is a single bump really worth the time? I guess that is my question. I'm not saying a disagree with rules, if that rule wasn't there it would be pretty chaotic. I'm just wondering if there is some flexibility to that rule. To me he had a pretty decent reason to bump.

No bumping and no number calling, I know.

Also MM, do note that I really value your contribution to the forums, you are a great and dedicated mod.


Thank you, your support is appreciated. However the bumping of threads does sometimes get out of hand and at some point needs to be stopped and as that sticky has been up for over six months I feel that it's time to start enforcing the "no bumping" rule otherwise there would no point in having such a rule, and what makes one thread more important than any of the others?

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
- 0 +

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.499321

Dear god that is a great combo. You should definitely get that. A beginning overclocker likely won't see a huge benefit from the HAWK, and that is a great PSU for a great deal.

------------------------------ Want Rock and Metal?

Paul Online Radio Network: http://www.paulradio.net/
Reply to AMW1011

I have researched and researched the GTX460 manufacturers, review after review, thread after thread. I came to the conclusion today that the MSI Cyclone is indeed, the best bang for your buck. All the reviews I have read greatly promoted the card and its price, and it is the easiest, safest, and most reliable card to over-clock. It also has extremely low temperatures under load, with the OC. It may suck more power than the AMD 5000's, but the GTX460's temps are much lower. Just check out any review of the card, all say the same thing. I bought mine today off of Newegg with the free game and rebate! Yes, the Hawk did just come out, but it will only OC better, and that's all it offers. I have read numerous reviews that the new "Cyclone cooler" is actually better than the Twin frozr II in some aspects. Get the Cyclone!

------------------------------ Core 2 Duo E8400 @ 3.00GHz | 6 gigs of RAM | Asus P5QC mobo | ASUS 4850 graphics | Corsair TX650 PSU | Windows 7 64 bit
Reply to cpoullas
- 0 +

Mousemonkey wrote :

Thank you, your support is appreciated. However the bumping of threads does sometimes get out of hand and at some point needs to be stopped and as that sticky has been up for over six months I feel that it's time to start enforcing the "no bumping" rule otherwise there would no point in having such a rule, and what makes one thread more important than any of the others?



That is a good point. The OP to this thread had good reason to bump I think, especially since the answer was pretty simple (Its not a "MY PC won't boot, why?" thread). However, I see your point that he can't be allowed to do it, even if its understandable, because then others will abuse it. Even a limited bump rule wouldn't work. The warning you gave, while sounding a little heavy handed to him I'm sure, is as lenient as you can possibly be. Its kind of sad that it has to be that way.

------------------------------ Want Rock and Metal?

Paul Online Radio Network: http://www.paulradio.net/
Reply to AMW1011

Rules are rules and sometimes they have to be enforced, I could get completely draconian and close any and every thread that gets bumped until people get the point that bumping threads is a no no but hopefully it won't come to that, only time will tell I suppose.

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey

In terms of which GTX460 to pick, it seems that most reviews favor the card that has the highest factory overclock. A lot of people seem to like the MSI Cyclone, but it's performance usually falls in the middle of the pack... that's because it only has a moderate factory overclock. If you were to overclock the card to the other cards' specs, I expect the performance would likely be similar.

Similarly, the heat and noise results from the Tom's article may be misleading. The MSI Cyclone wins that part of the review, but again, it has the lowest factory clock speeds, and therefore should run cooler and quieter, but at a lower performance point. Again, if you were to overclock the MSI Cyclone up to 800 mhz to match the Palit Sonic Platinum, the noise and heat would likely be similar (maybe even higher). An additional issue is that the MSI Cyclone vents heat inside your case, which may raise overall case temperatures, while the Palit, and others, exhaust their heat outside the case.

Based on just the Tom's article, I woul go for the Palit Sonic Platinum, which is almost as quiet as the MSI Cyclone, but has greater performance, and as the article shows a greater price/performance ratio.

For your reference, here are some other articles:

http://www.guru3d.com/article/geforce-gtx-460-review/1
http://www.guru3d.com/article/msi- [...] 4-review/1

------------------------------ MSI P55-GD80, Core i7-875K, Corsair A70 heatsink, PNY GTX580, 8GB Corsair Dominator RAM @ 1600mhz, Corsair 850HX PSU, WD Black 1 TB, WD Green 2 TB, Audigy 2, Antec Sonata, Cambridge Soundworks 5.1 THX speakers, Samsung P2770H 27" monitor, Windows 7 Ultima
Reply to matto17secs
- 0 +

I purchased 2 EVGA GTX 460s 1 Gig OC'ed from newegg to sli. One of the reasons for the EVGA card was the out of the Box exhaust. It seemed more inportrant to me that the hot air get out of my case than the small jump in performance I would see with the Palitt or the Cyclone. So far mine has been great, Idles at about 25C and loaded about 59C. I do have a HAF 932 case with a refridgerated unit ducted into the front 230mm fan though. My setup is in my Garage uninsulated....so if it is 100 outside it is 100 in the garage. The computer does fine out here....just needs dusting once a week, lol

Reply to Jack64
- 0 +

AMW1011 wrote :

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.499321

Dear god that is a great combo. You should definitely get that. A beginning overclocker likely won't see a huge benefit from the HAWK, and that is a great PSU for a great deal.



I was looking at this one at first, and yeah it's a great deal... then again I found this one...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.492896

It's an XFX 750watt - very highly reviewed (manufactured by seasonic, right?)

got a 9.7 on jonnyguru http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.p [...] t&reid=184

and I like the case. Cheap combo after discount and rebates...

In my overall build I'll come out a little cheaper, and with that case which is nicer than what I had picked, and as a little perk I can pair the Cyclone with the free game.

Reply to muckle

muckle wrote :

I was looking at this one at first, and yeah it's a great deal... then again I found this one...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Comb [...] mbo.492896

It's an XFX 750watt - very highly reviewed (manufactured by seasonic, right?)

got a 9.7 on jonnyguru http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.p [...] t&reid=184

and I like the case. Cheap combo after discount and rebates...

In my overall build I'll come out a little cheaper, and with that case which is nicer than what I had picked, and as a little perk I can pair the Cyclone with the free game.



Jesus those are both great combos, great case, great PSUs, great GPU. Its a tough decision, see if you can't get any other combos with the GPU besides that PSU one.

By the way, the HAWK, the Cyclone, and the DirectCU are the best 460s, I wouldn't get any others.

I'd probably go with the XFX PSU and Antec case just so you can SLI in the future.


Message edited by Helltech on 09-08-2010 at 01:11:04 AM
------------------------------ |CPU| i7 920 @ 3.8Ghz |MOBO| Rampage II |RAM| 12GB, 6*2Gig GSkill DDR3 |GPU| EVGA GTX 260 x2 SLI
|HDD| 300GB VelociRaptor + 2*1TB Caviar |Sound| X-Fi Titanium Fatal1ty |PSU| Corsair 750TX
|Case| XCLIO A380BK |CPUCooling| Zalman CNPS 9000 |OS| Vista 64
Reply to Helltech
- 0 +

I hope someone could review 460 based on SLI from several different vendor. I will buy 2 460 soon to build up another PC. I have read lots of customer review and found out the none reference cooling may give you trouble on second card since the fan will blow hot air to second card. I may stick with eVGA card which may get little bit noise than other none reference card but it wont have problem on cooling with sli. otherwise customer cooling solution for sli could fix it.

Reply to yanje03

My first choice would be the following option from MSI :

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127510 204.99 after rebate

I know you are looking to run SLI with gtx 460s but you could look at this card, buy one now and then purchase another one for SLI once the price drops:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127513

It is an overclocked GTX 470 but it keeps very low temps under full load. It would cost 319.00 after the rebate and only runs on average 5-8 fps lower than a regular GTX 480.

Reply to jones911

Mousemonkey wrote :

Thank you, your support is appreciated. However the bumping of threads does sometimes get out of hand and at some point needs to be stopped and as that sticky has been up for over six months I feel that it's time to start enforcing the "no bumping" rule otherwise there would no point in having such a rule, and what makes one thread more important than any of the others?



Well said.

As a former moderator, I'd just like to say that you've done a good job.

Reply to w0lfattack

I know you are not interested in competing cards, but again, another option is this Galaxy 470 After rebate it's in high end 460 price range. It idles around 40 degrees in my case, haven't stress tested it, but it did get to 78 in Crysis/Ultra high/noAA@1600x900. I also drilled for a fan installed on the bottom of my case to pull air in and blow directly into the gfx fan

Reply to ScoobyJooby-Jew

w0lfattack wrote :

Well said.

As a former moderator, I'd just like to say that you've done a good job.


Thank you.

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
- 0 +

Lotta controversy about the bump in here... Ok I see both sides. Bumping is annoying.

But I think this thread is a legitimate discussion about a popular piece of hardware so I was annoyed it wasn't catching on. Maybe everyone was out to lunch or something. I guess I could have waited longer... but it doesn't take long for a dormant post to trickle down the list... I could have devised a more subtle way of keeping it alive. If not I would have just started a new thread but I figured that was just as bad.

Reply to muckle

Well i purchased the asus 768 top edition and it runs better than the msi i think thats what i used to have i rmad it back for the asus for 2 reasons 1. the heat is inside your case not good imo and 2. the asus has voltage tweak and actual heatsinks that are worthy and every review has put it above the others heres a link of proof of the overclock also lol edit #2 lmfao
http://www.techpowerup.com/gpuz/8byf2/


Message edited by philly_87 on 09-08-2010 at 07:27:10 PM
------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1373490.png
Reply to philly_87

you can also bump the memory uo to 1840 but that doesnt do much

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1373490.png
Reply to philly_87

no one mentioned gigabyte. i just got my gigabyte gtx 460 in the mail. hoping i didn't make the wrong choiiice?!?

Reply to dandydaniel

dandydaniel wrote :

no one mentioned gigabyte. i just got my gigabyte gtx 460 in the mail. hoping i didn't make the wrong choiiice?!?



Its in the top 5, it just doesn't hold its own against the MSIs and the ASUS (and even Palit), in my opinion.

------------------------------ |CPU| i7 920 @ 3.8Ghz |MOBO| Rampage II |RAM| 12GB, 6*2Gig GSkill DDR3 |GPU| EVGA GTX 260 x2 SLI
|HDD| 300GB VelociRaptor + 2*1TB Caviar |Sound| X-Fi Titanium Fatal1ty |PSU| Corsair 750TX
|Case| XCLIO A380BK |CPUCooling| Zalman CNPS 9000 |OS| Vista 64
Reply to Helltech

dandydaniel wrote :

no one mentioned gigabyte. i just got my gigabyte gtx 460 in the mail. hoping i didn't make the wrong choiiice?!?



Nothing wrong with Gigabyte. :) I use one of their motherboards, and they make fantastic mobos. :)

------------------------------ i5-750 4Ghz @ 1.32V / Gigabyte GA-P55-UD4P / Xigmatek HDT-S1283
GTX 470 SLI / 8GB GSkill DDR3 1600 9-9-9-24 @1.5v
2 x WD Caviar Black 1TB / Thermaltake Armor BWS8003
Win 7 64bit / Antec TPQ-850 / Vantage P31806 / 3dMark06 25351 / 3dMark11 P7597
Reply to jerreece
- 0 +

dandydaniel wrote :

no one mentioned gigabyte. i just got my gigabyte gtx 460 in the mail. hoping i didn't make the wrong choiiice?!?


mine also gigabyte...last time also gigabyte 8600GT...no problem at all.....and if u want to SLi (refer to Kit Guru website) it...it can be one of the coolest duo

Reply to cpmboy
- 0 +



Just so you know dur_trix, we have previously proven that your comments about the GTX 460 are misinformed and your research is incomplete. The article you referenced is for the GTX 465 which is not the same as the GTX 460. The GTX 460 uses a different chip then the GTX 465 and the GTX 460 performs much better then the GTX 465. Please reference articles that relate to the discussion. Also, fan boyism is not helpful when trying to decide what card to use. ATI and NVidia are doing a decent job at the moment competing head to head at all levels. Please stop suggesting that people not buy the GTX 460 until you actually read the articles you are referencing.

Reply to deweycd


That's a review of the 465, which being a different GPU to the 460 means that it's not the same. What is it with you that you cannot understand that?

------------------------------ http://img545.imageshack.us/img545/3995/bl11.gif
Reply to Mousemonkey
- 0 +

Speaking of different GPU's, in the end I ended up buying this:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] -_-Product

After weighing the options and reading this:

http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] ,2713.html

I fell in love after reading the TH review. Imagine 2 of these bad boys in SLI....

Reply to muckle

Good job. With that great cooler, I would say that card may be the best price/performance option out of the entire GTX460, 465, 470, 480 line.

------------------------------ MSI P55-GD80, Core i7-875K, Corsair A70 heatsink, PNY GTX580, 8GB Corsair Dominator RAM @ 1600mhz, Corsair 850HX PSU, WD Black 1 TB, WD Green 2 TB, Audigy 2, Antec Sonata, Cambridge Soundworks 5.1 THX speakers, Samsung P2770H 27" monitor, Windows 7 Ultima
Reply to matto17secs
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphics & Displays > Graphics Cards > GTX 460 roundup - your pick
Go to:

There are 1857 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Bad PCI-E Slot or Bad Graphics Card?
By smorizio, 2 hours ago:

check that you have all the power cables plugged into your video card..some have one some...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts