Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Temp Sensors Seem Unreliable - Need Comparsions

Last response: in Components
Share
March 10, 2011 9:16:59 PM


CPU Phenom II 555 BE
Motherboard ASRock 870 Extreme 3
Memory G Skill 2 GB DDR3-1333 x2
Graphics Card MSI N450GTS-M2D1GD5/OC
Hard Drive Seagate 500 GB, 7200
Power Supply antec neo eco 520c
Case Cooler Master HAF 912
Monitor Compaq WF1907 [19" LCD]

I just ran Prime95 for 7 hour and left my CPU and case fans on FULL. I looked at the temperatures and fan speeds just before I stopped the torture test. This is the Stock AMD HSF and Stock HAF 912 Case Fans (2) on Full.

I've already found I have a problem in the fan controller sensor, when take the fans off Full and I set it to manual mode, it reads only one fan accurately and the other shows similar reading for 9 out of 10 every 10 seconds- then jumps to double the speed it was reading for 1 second or reads N/A in the Bios/Cmos.


Prime95@7hours RESULTS
CPU: 42-43 C (Core 1: 38 C & Core 2: 38 C)
MB: 31 C
CPU FAN: 3750
Chassis fan front: 1147-1200 RPM
Chassis fan rear: 1159-1180 RPM

What are reasonable temperatures? What are realistic fans speeds? Anything else odd on the reading?



Here's a screenshot:




Idol RESULTS
CPU: 31 C (Core 1: 21 C & Core 2: 21 C)
MB: 31 C

Are these accurate or inaccurate too... I need a baseline to figure out whether I have a fan controller issue only or fan controller and temp sensor issue too - The first I suppose I can live with - the second I probably would need to return the mobo to newegg (I've had it 2 weeks)...



thanks
JyK



a c 863 à CPUs
March 10, 2011 9:43:38 PM

Idle => Unlikely that your CPU core temp would be 21C. Most people have 20C+ or 68F+ ambient in their homes.
m
0
l
a b à CPUs
March 10, 2011 10:22:28 PM

...wow.

Hmm... I could do a quick disable of two of my 965's cores and see what temp results it gives me for a comparison, but I doubt even then it would be anywhere around there. Our setups are basically the same, only my case is the CM 690 II Advanced with a Core Contact Freezer... I know how far that drops my temps, though, so it shouldn't be a problem.


Huh. That's interesting. I'll look into this and get back to you in the near future.
m
0
l
a c 103 à CPUs
March 11, 2011 10:05:18 AM

I have built 4 AMD machines in the last year ish 1 with a Phenom x2 and 3 with Athlon x3s and none report remotely accurate core temps, ie the PC i am typing this on reports 2 cores at 11C 1 at 12C when the room temp is 19C. I recommend you go by the CPU temp and ignore the cores totally. If you do that your temps all look fine and accurate. My Athlon x3 is currently idle ish at 26C (7C above room temp) but I an using a hyper 212+ on a system thats not overclocked (I had one spare if you are wondering why).
m
0
l
!