To be honest it depends as well what games you are wanting to play.
Some are better suited than others and dont get me wrong, i have often contemplated many times about 3 or 4 way sli for a nuts rig, but its the drivers that let them down.
To my knowledge and someone correct me if I am wrong but two 570's doesn't mean 200% performance. I think it translates to 150/160% which kinda sucks.... but it is also the reason why i believe a single card will run better, ok it may not churn out as many PPD for the folders out there but for raw gaming, there is little that can match the Nvidia 580 pound for pound.
If i was you i would buy a single 580, get an EVGA one they have a 10 year guarantee
then if this isn't enough after 6months simply get another !
Please remember though that this does mean you need a good MOBO and quick CPU, NO DUAL CORE's PLEASE!
Screen wise, go 1900 x 1200 as an absolute minimum otherwise this graphics grunt you have will be wasted.
I hope this helps