Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Seasonic S12II-380 REAIL vs. Seasonic SS-400 OEM

Last response: in Components
Share
March 25, 2011 2:51:21 AM

I just bought a Seasonic S12II-380 for my HTPC build on an Antec Fusion, powering MSI-890 motherboard with onboard Radeon 4290, Athlon X4-640, 4GB DDR3, 2 SATA HDD, DVDRW.

For SOME REASON, the one I got is NOT 80plus Bronze, and only is 80plus! While all Seasonic S12II models on their website are 80plus Bronze! I looked around locally and no one could gaurantee a 80+ Bronze model.

Seasonic S12II-380

Alternatively, I can get an OEM Seasonic SS-400ET, which IS 80+ Bronze, OR, have to move up S12II-520.

Seasonic SS-400ET

Seasonic S12II-520

To me it looks like they're identical otherwise, any idea which would be a better buy for my HTPC, should I assume retail one is quieter and has better components? Local prices are SS-400ES $42, S12II-380 $60, S12II-520 $75.

Apart from retail packaging, and cable sleeves, is the retail one actually better PSU even if it's NOT 80+ Bronze?

Thanks
a b ) Power supply
March 25, 2011 9:05:36 AM

the 380 unit is fine for your purpose. i would not waste the hassle changing anything now that you have it. if you must, get the antec earthwatts 380, its probably cheaper and is manufactured by seasonic.
m
0
l
a c 1196 ) Power supply
March 25, 2011 6:54:02 PM

The Seasonic S12II Series has recently been discontinued and replaced by the S12II Bronze Series.

Seasonic must be clearing out the S12II Series stock that is still in the distribution channel.

I've also noticed that the 5 year warranty on the S12II Series is now down to only 3 years on the S12II Bronze Series.

The OEM units don't have the fancy packaging and paint job (plain flat light grey), don't have cable sleeving and have shorter cables (4" to 6" shorter).

The retail units are quieter than their OEM equivalent.
m
0
l
Related resources
March 25, 2011 7:15:25 PM

ko888 said:
The Seasonic S12II Series has recently been discontinued and replaced by the S12II Bronze Series.

Seasonic must be clearing out the S12II Series stock that is still in the distribution channel.

I've also noticed that the 5 year warranty on the S12II Series is now down to only 3 years on the S12II Bronze Series.

The OEM units don't have the fancy packaging and paint job (plain flat light grey), don't have cable sleeving and have shorter cables (4" to 6" shorter).

The retail units are quieter than their OEM equivalent.


So, it's worth paying $20 more for the non-Bronze retail version vs. Bronze OEM one? I got a power cable, so I don't care and apart from looking nicer, I am not sure what cable sleeves do for a PSU?!

Are they really quieter though? How? Using different fans? or having better components inside?

Thnx
m
0
l
a c 1196 ) Power supply
March 25, 2011 8:50:27 PM

alexb75 said:
So, it's worth paying $20 more for the non-Bronze retail version vs. Bronze OEM one? I got a power cable, so I don't care and apart from looking nicer, I am not sure what cable sleeves do for a PSU?!

Are they really quieter though? How? Using different fans? or having better components inside?

Thnx

What does having a power cable have to do with cable sleeving?

Sleeving makes cable management within the HTPC's case easier. It also reduces the blockage of airflow through the HTPC's case.

The fan in the OEM unit ramps up sooner starting a t 50% PSU load whereas the retail unit starts to ramp up at 75% PSU load. At 100% PSU load the OEM version's fan noise is clearly audible and the retail version's isn't.

No cable sleeving:


Sleeved cables:
m
0
l
March 25, 2011 10:49:57 PM

Thanks, then I guess I will keep my S12-II, although it's not 80+ Bronze!
m
0
l
a c 1196 ) Power supply
March 25, 2011 11:06:13 PM

alexb75 said:
Thanks, then I guess I will keep my S12-II, although it's not 80+ Bronze!

80 PLUS BRONZE guarantees nothing. See the Efficiency Comparison in this chart:

http://www.anandtech.com/show/2697/39
m
0
l
!