Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Closed

5850 Vapor X vs 6870

Last response: in Graphics & Displays
Share
November 30, 2010 10:09:43 PM

Hi all,

I am stuck between a difficult choice, between 5850 Vapor-X and 6870. Money is not really the issue because I am getting them used from someone, around the same price. My first priority would be noise level @ load, then the rest. I know 6870 is a tad bit faster than 5850 at clock speed and 5850 has more room for OC potential. I do not plan to get 6900 series or crossfire in the future because of my budget.

Noise level wise, I don't know if there is any difference @ load, because I normally manually set my idle fan speed to inaudible, and I can't find enough information on both cards regarding their noise level, that is why I am confused. Temperature is not really an issue, my case is well ventilated. I am leaning towards 6870 if the dba level is about the same at +50% load. If anyone know first hand or know any information about it, thanks in advance

Thanks,

More about : 5850 vapor 6870

Best solution

a b U Graphics card
November 30, 2010 10:12:52 PM


The 5850 is definitely quieter, thats what that model is all about.
Its also a center fan, exhaust heat internal model which are usally quieter to start with.
The 6870' reference model uses a blower fan and they operate at fairly high rpm to pull air in and exhaust out the case.
Share
November 30, 2010 10:22:21 PM

Thanks for the lightning reply.

Hmm with noise level aside, is there any significant advantage 6870 has over 5850? I don't really care about a few fps more or less. Far as I know, 6870 is better when it comes to tesselation and morphological aa. I read that morphological aa smoothes edges out, etc. Is it worth it?

Thanks again,

EDIT: just read that 5000 series can also use this new feature morphological aa soon.
Score
0
Related resources
a b U Graphics card
November 30, 2010 10:43:40 PM

The 5850 is a excellent card. Advantage of 6850 is price. Real world actual games where the tesselation performance would make a difference is hard to quantify.
6870 is a higher clocked slightly better performing 6850.
A o/c 5850 or 5870 is generally the same or slightly faster. They are all in the same ball park. And thats with the fastest cpu's.
AMD made the 68XX series a little cheaper to manufacture and they are now their higher - mid range cards. Their new flagship cards will be the 69XX .
So the old 58XX compare to the new 68XX very evenly.
Score
0
November 30, 2010 11:16:24 PM

Hmm, true I am not an enthusiastist, don't care much about benchmarks. And yes I do agree it's hard to identity the significant differences in reality. That's why I considered 5850, because it's mid-range performance at 1900 res and good price/performance ratio. 6800 series is just a slight improvement over 5770/5850 with a few new features and I think mainly marketing towards nvidia new line ups.

Anyway, thanks a lot notty. Appreciate the replies within minutes, I just needed some reassurance since I am not an expert when it comes to hardware, but I know enough. Hoping to order within next week, busy this week ;/
Score
0
a b U Graphics card
November 30, 2010 11:49:20 PM

Mostly yes , except the 5770 is not in the same class with the above cards. A good gpu, but a o/c 5870 is the master of 2-5770's.
I ran a o/c 4770 which itself could play a lot of 1900x1080 dx9 games like a 5770 can do with dx11 games. But you are more often than not, turning down many IQ settings for FPS. Its nice to get a slightly 'overkill' gpu , to leave everything on HIGH .
Score
0
December 1, 2010 12:47:26 AM

I agree, I had a 5770 before and it was decent performance on 1900 on med settings, max on 1680 res OC. I considered about cross-firing but the temp/noise turned me off in the end. Eventually sold it and using a replacement until next purchase. I actually almost bought 2x 4770 before 5000 series came out, but I am glad I waited, but this time I need it before the holidays!
Score
0
December 1, 2010 5:22:35 PM

Best answer selected by marshmallow905.
Score
0
a c 271 U Graphics card
December 1, 2010 6:38:42 PM

This topic has been closed by Mousemonkey
Score
0
!