Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Cheap motherboard for Phenom II X3 HTPC

Last response: in Motherboards
March 12, 2012 11:55:52 AM

I have a spare Phenom II X3 710 and low profile Radeon 5550, and I want to stick them (and a spare 320GB hard disk) in an Enermax Laguna case and make that into an HTPC (which will be used for video viewing/capture and perhaps a little gaming).

I'm planning to buy a cheap micro-ATX motherboard and have several options (these are the options available at the store where I plan to buy the case):

1. Biostar A880G
Pros: newish chipset; HDMI slot nice as a backup (though not really necessary)
Cons: no info on the web (only A880G+); Biostar has a crappy site; no PCIe x1 (I might want to stick a video capture card there)

2. ASRock 960GM-S3 FX
Pros: PCIe x1 slot; ASRock utilities (XFast stuff in particular) sound nice; AM3+ so more future proof
Cons: PCIe x1 slot is adjacent to the graphics card

3. Gigabyte GA-M68MT-S2P (rev 3.0, probably, couldn't get a definitive answer)
Pros: Two PCIe x1 slots, one not adjacent to the graphics card; I've owned several Gigabyte MB's and never had problems with them
Cons: Old chipset (lower HT speed, probably first gen PCIe)

I think that option 1 doesn't have any real benefit, so the choice is between 2 and 3. What do you think?

I'm leaning more towards option 3 because I found another store which sells the case and its prices are cheaper, and it doesn't have option 2. Still, the low HT speed and first gen PCIe bother me. Don't know if they'd really matter though (the PCIe version probably not, considering the low end card).
March 12, 2012 1:22:54 PM

Went with the Gigabyte. I eventually found a store that was not only cheaper but also local, and that pretty much decided things for me.
Related resources
March 12, 2012 2:29:54 PM

You're right. This is actually available at the store where I ended up buying the things. Costs about $15 more, which isn't a big deal but I don't know if it's worth it. What I don't get is why these boards always have so many legacy ports. I'd rather have another couple of USB ports.

And thanks for the reply.
March 12, 2012 3:09:13 PM

I checked and there's also the Gigabyte GA-MA78LM-S2H in the price range of the ASUS. But I like that the GA-M68MT-S2P has that distant PCIe slot. I checked and the HIS 5550 has a heat sink on both sides of the card, so the slot above the card will be blocked and the slot below will be too adjacent.
March 19, 2012 1:24:48 PM

So which MB did you get?
March 19, 2012 1:28:27 PM

The Gigabyte. I'll be picking up that PC in about an hour (I paid for the store to assemble the parts, to save time and because I don't want to find out what an inquisitive toddler can do to PC hardware).
March 26, 2012 7:24:33 AM

Having used the PC a bit by now, I can say that the one inconvenience I encountered due to using this board was not being able to run AMD Overdrive, because the board doesn't have an AMD chipset. It's not a huge deal because there are other utilities to do the same things, but I would have liked to be able to run it.