Most motherboards will 10 years or more. I see no reason why a Biostar motherboard would be less reliable than an Asus. I built a system based on a Biostar motherboard and it's been running fine for several years. The color shouldn't be a selection criteria.
Make sure that you can install an ATX motherboard before buying one. Your original selection was a mATX motherboard, but you didn't say if size or cost was the criteria.