Archived from groups: rec.games.video.nintendo,alt.games.video.nintendo.gameboy.advance (More info?)
So E3 is over. Ands what and E3 it was, more exciting than any in recent
memory. Of course the stars of the show were the Nintendo DS and the Sony
PSP.
During the show I paid little attention the the PSP, I already knew what it
was and what it had to offer, so my attention was focussed on the DS, and
man was I excited.
However, the excitement has left me and I am actually left with a little bit
of frustration. I like certain things about both systems, hate other things,
and I wish more than anything I could merge them together into one.
DS Pros:
-the double screen idea is great. touch screen even better.
-the variety of games demoed is extremely impressive. The innovation on
display was unprecedeted, IMO, and I can't wait to play these games.
-lots and lots of developer support.
-long battery life
-clamshell design to portect the screens.
-price will probably be right.
DS cons:
-apparently still a pitiful low resolution of 256x192. Marginally better
than GBA, but not better than NES. Sure there are two of them, but they are
an inch apart and only one is displaying 3d graphics at a time, that doesn't
really help. Rumoured that these are STILL not backlit, but frontlit. :-(
-no analog control. I am personally not crazy about using the stylus for
that purpose.
-It is clunky looking. defnitely needs refinement before release. The PSP is
lightyears beyond in form. I know the Nintendo fanboys will force themselves
to disagree, but even Craig Harris, the biggest Nintendo geek around
acknowledges this.
-Only N64 quality 3d. I don't know about you, but I have never liked N64
quality 3d, in fact going back to play n64 games is pretty difficult these
days. Granted Metroid looks pretty damn good, but I have a feeling it will
be the exception...
-Once again a low capacity media. Better than GBA, but 128mb is still not
much. I expect games will suffer in the sound department, and either
textures or games lenght will suffer. :-(
-may be limited to quirky "friendly" games, may not see GTA and it's
relatives.
PSP Pros:
-BIG BEAUTIFUL SCREEN! 480x272! Backlit and bright as a laptop.
-very pretty 3d quality
-analog stick that apparently works very well.
-nice sleek design.
- huge media capacity.
- lots of developer support
- will surely get plenty of so called mature games, like GTA etc.
PSP cons:
-battery life expected to be terible.
-not very original, basically a tiny PS2
-high porduction costs may result in a lot of ports
-screen will get scratched
- will be expenisve
As you can see my list of cons for the DS is much longer than that for the
PSP. Even so I still favour the DS. I just wish to hell that I could have a
DS with an analog stick and the PSP's screen for at least the top screen.
So E3 is over. Ands what and E3 it was, more exciting than any in recent
memory. Of course the stars of the show were the Nintendo DS and the Sony
PSP.
During the show I paid little attention the the PSP, I already knew what it
was and what it had to offer, so my attention was focussed on the DS, and
man was I excited.
However, the excitement has left me and I am actually left with a little bit
of frustration. I like certain things about both systems, hate other things,
and I wish more than anything I could merge them together into one.
DS Pros:
-the double screen idea is great. touch screen even better.
-the variety of games demoed is extremely impressive. The innovation on
display was unprecedeted, IMO, and I can't wait to play these games.
-lots and lots of developer support.
-long battery life
-clamshell design to portect the screens.
-price will probably be right.
DS cons:
-apparently still a pitiful low resolution of 256x192. Marginally better
than GBA, but not better than NES. Sure there are two of them, but they are
an inch apart and only one is displaying 3d graphics at a time, that doesn't
really help. Rumoured that these are STILL not backlit, but frontlit. :-(
-no analog control. I am personally not crazy about using the stylus for
that purpose.
-It is clunky looking. defnitely needs refinement before release. The PSP is
lightyears beyond in form. I know the Nintendo fanboys will force themselves
to disagree, but even Craig Harris, the biggest Nintendo geek around
acknowledges this.
-Only N64 quality 3d. I don't know about you, but I have never liked N64
quality 3d, in fact going back to play n64 games is pretty difficult these
days. Granted Metroid looks pretty damn good, but I have a feeling it will
be the exception...
-Once again a low capacity media. Better than GBA, but 128mb is still not
much. I expect games will suffer in the sound department, and either
textures or games lenght will suffer. :-(
-may be limited to quirky "friendly" games, may not see GTA and it's
relatives.
PSP Pros:
-BIG BEAUTIFUL SCREEN! 480x272! Backlit and bright as a laptop.
-very pretty 3d quality
-analog stick that apparently works very well.
-nice sleek design.
- huge media capacity.
- lots of developer support
- will surely get plenty of so called mature games, like GTA etc.
PSP cons:
-battery life expected to be terible.
-not very original, basically a tiny PS2
-high porduction costs may result in a lot of ports
-screen will get scratched
- will be expenisve
As you can see my list of cons for the DS is much longer than that for the
PSP. Even so I still favour the DS. I just wish to hell that I could have a
DS with an analog stick and the PSP's screen for at least the top screen.