sound-asleep said:
Thanks for all the suggestions! It looks like the 2600K would be about $50 more, plus I imagine a mobo with a newly-released chipset (z68) will probably run quite a bit more than $200. I'd have to figure out if the speed increase justifies the increased cost. I assume the video transcribing aspect wouldn't matter much if I have a 6850? Or am I misunderstanding that? I wonder if maybe spending an extra ~$40 on on an i7 960 would be a good compromise?
You are right the I-7 950 is dropping in price because the 2600k blows its doors off and doesn't cost that much more. You could also go to the I-7 2500K which is still has Quick Sync and it is also screaming fast CPU - it almost keeps up with the 2600K. It is about $100.00 cheaper than the 2600K and Tom's Hardware recommends it as the best CPU for the buck.
Concerning the ATI 6850 there are two different video issues to keep track of.
1. Which is better to use the 6850 or Quick Sync to transcribe your video? Hands down, Quick Sync decisively beats ANY video card when transcribing
2. When you WATCH the HD video that you have transcribed, that is where you need a good quality discrete video card. The 6850 should do a wonderful job in getting a great picture to your monitor (you do need a decent monitor also to appreciate the quality of the signal that the card is producing)
I read a review that rated the video (when you watch video on your monitor quality) quality of all of the current ATI video cards and GTX cards. Any ATI card from the 5770 up beat all of the GTX cards. ATI simply produces better video to watch than GTX (Nvidia). However, since there is very little cost difference between the 5770 and the 6850, the 6850 is a great choice and gives you plenty of power to process HD video.
We don't know what the Z68 mobos will cost but I am willing to bet that there will be an ASUS Z68 mobo in the $200 - $250 range. Just make sure that you get Lucid Logic's software with it because it will let you use both Quick Sync and the 6850 discrete GPU. Their website is here:
http://www.lucidlogix.com/product-virtu.html Tom's Hardware has a review that explains what it is. You absolutely need it with the Z68 platform. Many mobo manufacturers are including it with their motherboards. I think ASUS is going to include it with its Z68 mobos.
It is better to get the 2500K or the 2600K CPUs because you can overclock these CPUs fairly easily (especially with an ASUS mobo) and make them screaming fast. The 2500K beats the $1000.00 Intel I-7 990 in most benchmarks when it is overclocked and yet it costs only $225.00.