You should be fine with the same board, unless you really feel compelled to get a different one. Issues like these aren't really common, but do happen. At least it didn't take anything with it (hopefully).
I filed for a return from Amazon late last night. UPS should be picking it up tomorrow.
Well, I looked online, and only saw one scenario of something similar happening. http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1596733
Looks pretty identical to me, so I can pretty much say it wasn't user error on my part, right? >.<
Anyway, thanks for the help. :3 Let's see if anyone has any more that want to add on the topic.