Sorry if you guys get a lot of these, but I don't want to just look up someone else's case thread and buy what's suggested for them. I don't want to go and buy the HAF X just because the hundreds of internet masses tell me it's the best. I'll admit, originally I sought out the flash and the LED-fans, but having thought about it for going on near a month now... I realize the flash isn't important. I want to focus on finding a case that feels good to me, not that just looks good to people I invite over. I've been hearing a LOT of different things from different people, but I've been saving Tom's Hardware for last because generally... I trust you guys the most with this stuff (for big non-mobile computer anyway).
My first point is Filters, I am personally really annoyed with dust so my first instinct was to seek out cases with 100% filter coverage. This was surprisingly hard because reviews are often very vague regarding filters. They will tell you the case has "some", but not which slots are left open. Or they will call a "mesh" a filter, when in truth it has holes over a milimeter in diameter. I'm sorry but that's not a filter... Another I've heard is that filters are, at their heart, a gimmick. That real dust (the kind that sticks to your hardware like a bad paint job) is so fine nothing that lets air-flow through will really stop it. And if you really protected your case from all dust, you would ultimately create heat-pockets and risk damaging your build. I don't know if this is true or not... and I'd like some second (and third) opinions regarding that.
Next is Color, I had my eye out for some cases with nice white accents (I'll admit I wanted the Level 10 GT snow edition for a while). I heard a passing comment on a YouTube review that after just a few years, most white plastics fade to an ugly yellow, even if you don't smoke. Rebutals stated this is only true for old plastic and not modern ones, and that this only risks happening if you expose your case to UV sunlight 24/7. I'd rather not spend 300+ dollars on a beautiful white case if it winds up staining before 3 years are through.
Steel vs Plastic. My current case is a little cheap (and tiny, it has a microATX) but it's all metal, so it feels good. It's a thin metal though, so it would probably dent easily. My main concern is that plastic feels cheap, but metal always seems thin and dent-susceptible. I was watching a review of the LIAN LI PC-Z60B Black, which is supposedly the end-all simple solid all metal case, and the side panel just looks… thin. I feel like I’ll bump a notch in it if my elbow runs away from me and knocks it. On the other hand, I hear all these stories about pieces of plastic that just sometimes… snap right off. Even on expensive full towers made by reliable companies. I understand that there is inherent risk in everything… but I would like a case that is KNOWN for being indestructible, or damn well near it. And one that isn’t discontinued, ideally.
Mobo Compatibility. I actually have this weird DTX format, but it’s intercompatible with ATX/microATX boards. So any case that can support those two will probably support mine, and so that’s not too much of a worry. I doubt I am going to buy myself an E-ATX any time soon…
Air flow. For this, again, I’m not too worried. Apart for the whole filter thing impeding the flow… But yeah, I don’t plan on overclocking. I doubt I am going to be setting up any SLI/Crossfire in this case either, so it’s probably going to be reasonably low power, low heat. One of the reasons I’m hesitating with the HAF X, those intakes/exhaust fans are ridiculously large. It would probably wind up being overkill.
Side window/LED fans/Front-USB 3.0/Front-Fan-controls… those are all OK, but they are not a priority. Solidity should come before all that. I plan on having 1 optical drive, maybe 1 media-card reader (if they still make those, the kind you can pop right into a 5.25 inch bay). I doubt I’ll need more than 4 HD bays. I do want good cable management, but I think that’s pretty standard in cases these days.
My first point is Filters, I am personally really annoyed with dust so my first instinct was to seek out cases with 100% filter coverage. This was surprisingly hard because reviews are often very vague regarding filters. They will tell you the case has "some", but not which slots are left open. Or they will call a "mesh" a filter, when in truth it has holes over a milimeter in diameter. I'm sorry but that's not a filter... Another I've heard is that filters are, at their heart, a gimmick. That real dust (the kind that sticks to your hardware like a bad paint job) is so fine nothing that lets air-flow through will really stop it. And if you really protected your case from all dust, you would ultimately create heat-pockets and risk damaging your build. I don't know if this is true or not... and I'd like some second (and third) opinions regarding that.
Next is Color, I had my eye out for some cases with nice white accents (I'll admit I wanted the Level 10 GT snow edition for a while). I heard a passing comment on a YouTube review that after just a few years, most white plastics fade to an ugly yellow, even if you don't smoke. Rebutals stated this is only true for old plastic and not modern ones, and that this only risks happening if you expose your case to UV sunlight 24/7. I'd rather not spend 300+ dollars on a beautiful white case if it winds up staining before 3 years are through.
Steel vs Plastic. My current case is a little cheap (and tiny, it has a microATX) but it's all metal, so it feels good. It's a thin metal though, so it would probably dent easily. My main concern is that plastic feels cheap, but metal always seems thin and dent-susceptible. I was watching a review of the LIAN LI PC-Z60B Black, which is supposedly the end-all simple solid all metal case, and the side panel just looks… thin. I feel like I’ll bump a notch in it if my elbow runs away from me and knocks it. On the other hand, I hear all these stories about pieces of plastic that just sometimes… snap right off. Even on expensive full towers made by reliable companies. I understand that there is inherent risk in everything… but I would like a case that is KNOWN for being indestructible, or damn well near it. And one that isn’t discontinued, ideally.
Mobo Compatibility. I actually have this weird DTX format, but it’s intercompatible with ATX/microATX boards. So any case that can support those two will probably support mine, and so that’s not too much of a worry. I doubt I am going to buy myself an E-ATX any time soon…
Air flow. For this, again, I’m not too worried. Apart for the whole filter thing impeding the flow… But yeah, I don’t plan on overclocking. I doubt I am going to be setting up any SLI/Crossfire in this case either, so it’s probably going to be reasonably low power, low heat. One of the reasons I’m hesitating with the HAF X, those intakes/exhaust fans are ridiculously large. It would probably wind up being overkill.
Side window/LED fans/Front-USB 3.0/Front-Fan-controls… those are all OK, but they are not a priority. Solidity should come before all that. I plan on having 1 optical drive, maybe 1 media-card reader (if they still make those, the kind you can pop right into a 5.25 inch bay). I doubt I’ll need more than 4 HD bays. I do want good cable management, but I think that’s pretty standard in cases these days.