Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > [Solved] Intel or AMD for gaming?

[Solved] Intel or AMD for gaming?

Forum CPU & Components : CPUs [Solved] Intel or AMD for gaming?

Best answer from esrever.

Word :    Username :           
 

I'm wanting to build a system myself and don't know if I want to get an AMD or Intel CPU. It's my understanding that AMDs come unlocked by default and can be overclocked opposed to Intel, where you either have to buy one of the higher end Core i7s or get a "K" series that is unlocked. I don't plan to play like Crysis or anything but would like something that is fast and can handle a decent load for simulation type gaming

Reply to Tech_geek23
Register or log in to remove.

despite what other people say, you dont really need an 2500k to game. only games a cpu makes a huge difference is mmos and huge fps online games 32+ people

Reply to kemo_90
Best answer

whats your budget?
below $800 I'd consider going with AMD.

If you can get an i5 within your budget and not sacrifice gpu then theres no reason to get amd.

------------------------------ sllaw eht no nettirw gnihtemos saw ecno ereht
Reply to esrever

Depends on your budget. As long as it's 3ghz and has 4 cores your golden.

 

You only need a 2500K or something if your running 2 or more high end video cards, otherwise your always going to be gpu limited before your cpu limited and it's just overkill.

  

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by geekapproved on 01-14-2012 at 12:43:55 AM
------------------------------ Core i3-2100/Asrock H61/8GB1333/XFX HD5850oc/WD Black 500/Antec 300/Antec EA380w bronze
Currently playing Deus Ex:HR a second time on Hardcore
Reply to geekapproved

esrever wrote :

whats your budget?
below $800 I'd consider going with AMD.

If you can get an i5 within your budget and not sacrifice gpu then theres no reason to get amd.




This is probably not good to say, but I'm not definite on my exact budget yet. When you say "and not sacrifice gpu..." I'm not sure of exactly what you're saying.

Reply to Tech_geek23

geekapproved wrote :

You only need a 2500K or something if your running 2 or more high end video cards, otherwise your always going to be gpu limited before your cpu limited and it's just overkill.



Unless of course it's Skyrim... or maybe Skyrim's sequel. :)

Reply to larkspur

given a resolution you'd want a good gpu to be able to play on that resolution, you'd want the best gpu you can buy that will be efficient for that resolution then you want a cpu that will be good enough to drive that gpu during games. you have to balance gpu and cpu power in a system.

generally you spend 2x as much on gpu as you do on cpu. But you don't need to spend over $400 on a gpu if you are gaming on a low resolution.

------------------------------ sllaw eht no nettirw gnihtemos saw ecno ereht
Reply to esrever

Tech_geek23 wrote :

I'm wanting to build a system myself and don't know if I want to get an AMD or Intel CPU. It's my understanding that AMDs come unlocked by default and can be overclocked opposed to Intel, where you either have to buy one of the higher end Core i7s or get a "K" series that is unlocked. I don't plan to play like Crysis or anything but would like something that is fast and can handle a decent load for simulation type gaming



Actually most CPUs can be overclocked, but this is easier with an unlocked multiplier. These are special edition CPUs, so not all AMD processors feature this option.

How to tell the difference? With older AMD models such as Phenom I and II, the black edition refers to an unlocked multi. With newer models, the FX line of CPUs currently all feature unlocked CPUs. With the A75 platform APUs, AMD has stolen the "K" designation from Intel. Such as the latest to debut, the AMD A8 3870K.

So for Intel, the unlocked multiplier is seen in either the "K" series processors, or the Extreme Edition 8 core CPUs. Typically, the Intel CPUs see higher overclocking potential and also higher performance per clock than AMD. So Intel is a high end supplier and AMD is a budget provider, both in terms of price and performance.

What's important to know is what your needs are and budgetary concerns, but a fine system can be built using either CPU maker. The only way that I can see that AMD simply can not provide the same experience is in the case of running an extremely taxing game like Battlefield 3 at the highest settings and at high resolutions beyond what most PC users need.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/2331227.png
Reply to buzznut

buzznut wrote :

Actually most CPUs can be overclocked, but this is easier with an unlocked multiplier. These are special edition CPUs, so not all AMD processors feature this option.

How to tell the difference? With older AMD models such as Phenom I and II, the black edition refers to an unlocked multi. With newer models, the FX line of CPUs currently all feature unlocked CPUs. With the A75 platform APUs, AMD has stolen the "K" designation from Intel. Such as the latest to debut, the AMD A8 3870K.

So for Intel, the unlocked multiplier is seen in either the "K" series processors, or the Extreme Edition 8 core CPUs. Typically, the Intel CPUs see higher overclocking potential and also higher performance per clock than AMD. So Intel is a high end supplier and AMD is a budget provider, both in terms of price and performance.

What's important to know is what your needs are and budgetary concerns, but a fine system can be built using either CPU maker. The only way that I can see that AMD simply can not provide the same experience is in the case of running an extremely taxing game like Battlefield 3 at the highest settings and at high resolutions beyond what most PC users need.



Thanks for the clarification on that. So if I were to get a non-K series i5, what would be the best route to OC'ing it?

Reply to Tech_geek23

you need a motherboard that has some oc options and you will just make it run at max turbo always and also slightly increase the base clock to get a little extra.

you'd get maybe 100mhz over the max turbo if you are lucky.

------------------------------ sllaw eht no nettirw gnihtemos saw ecno ereht
Reply to esrever

esrever wrote :

you need a motherboard that has some oc options and you will just make it run at max turbo always and also slightly increase the base clock to get a little extra.

you'd get maybe 100mhz over the max turbo if you are lucky.



+1. Unfortunately, the non-K versions of the Sandy bridge CPUs are not great overclockers. So it is worth the extra $10 or whatever for the unlocked multiplier. Also more effective since unlocked multi's allow for only overclocking the CPU as opposed to reference clock or FSB overclocking which affects other components.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/2331227.png
Reply to buzznut
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > [Solved] Intel or AMD for gaming?
Go to:

There are 2070 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Case with filters. Recommendations?
By al360ex, 8 hours ago:

Then I'd go with one of these cases. If you choose the HAF 932 Advanced Edition, you...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts