Archived from groups: alt.games.video.xbox (
More info?)
On Thu, 26 May 2005 16:11:03 +0200, Thomas Jespersen
<thomas@lucky-music.dk> wrote:
>One of the first reasonable comparisons I have seen:
>
>http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,1558,1820495,00.asp
Not alot of meat in the article though with regard real specs and
performance. I really wonder if gamers want such overwhelming
functionality too. With both the xbox 360 and the ps3 setting
themselves up as quite expensive consoles I wonder if Nintendo's
Revolution might not be the real winner. Its being designed to perform
well but be cheap to manufacture. If the Revolution ends up selling at
$99 6 months after release and the Xbox is still at $199 or more the
Nintendo will have a lot of extra appeal. Especially if the Nintendo
has a simple plug in and go approach and can be moved easily from room
to room and house to house. Add to that no doubt improved stability
over the xbox 360's very complicated operating system.
The fact the Revolution has wifi built in and can download classic
Nintendo games for free (probably) in addition to playing gamecube
games and Revolution games that will probably be comparable to 360/PS3
games.
Maybe an all encompassing multimedia console is what people are
waiting for but I'm not sure. To be honest it will be much more
restrictive than a pc and it will remove a lot of freedom. Its obvious
Microsoft intends to make extra money from pipeing down movies and
other multimedia content to the 360. It will take on cable, satellite,
conventional tv and home pcs.
Thats the gloss but the reality is probably going to be a buggy
console with a hugely complicated operating system and even the
original xbox compatibility sounds like its going to be fairly
mediocre emulation that will only allow it to work with top games and
not all games.
Personally I'd prefer a Xbox 360 lite that just plays Xbox 360 games
as well as the main 360 console and has no dvd playback or xbox
support and doesn't have all the online/broadband functionality. I
stopped using Xbox Live as it simply wasn't worth it. My bandwidth is
often used for downloading movies etc so it wasn't practical and I
personally prefer the scripted events of first person shooters in
single player mode rather than constantly running after other players
and repeatedly shooting them in the same arena over and over again.