Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Systems > Prebuilt > Which pc should I buy? Intel i3 2100 or amd Phenom II 521?

Which pc should I buy? Intel i3 2100 or amd Phenom II 521?

Forum Systems : Prebuilt Which pc should I buy? Intel i3 2100 or amd Phenom II 521?

Word :    Username :           
 

Hi, my old computer recently got a bad svchost virus, so I'm thinking it's time for an upgrade. I have my eye on two refurbished PCs and was wondering which one is the better deal. Note: my old pc is an outdated pentium 4 with a geforce 6200 graphics card, so these PCs would be big upgrades to me.

For $340:
HP Pavilion Desktop Computer featuring Intel Core i3-2100 Processor (P7-1027)

Processor Type: Intel Core i3-2100
Processor Speed: 3.1 GHz
Processor Cores: 2
RAM: 6 GB PC3-10600 DDR3 SDRAM (Exp. To 8 GB)
Hard Drive Capacity: 750 GB SATA
Hard Drive Speed: 7200 RPM
Graphics: Intel HD
Pre-loaded Operating System: Windows 7 Home Premium 64-Bit

or for $250:
HP Pavilion Desktop Computer featuring AMD Phenom II 521 Dual Core (P6823W)

Processor Type: AMD Phenom II 521
Processor Speed: 3.5 GHz
Processor Cores: 2
RAM: 4 GB PC3-10600 DDR3 SDRAM (Exp. To 16 GB)
Hard Drive Capacity: 1 TB SATA
Hard Drive Speed: 7200 RPM
Graphics: ATI Radeon HD 4200
Pre-loaded Operating System: Windows 7 Home Premium 64-Bit

I'm looking for a cheap computer that would be decent for multi-tasking, I do a lot of website creation and 3d modelling/game programming using Blender. I'm a casual gamer, my favorite game being Medieval Total War II.

Which pc is the better deal? Is the i3 a big step up on the phenom (Which I've read is actually a re-named Athlon II)? For comparison, what games could these PCs run at medium settings? Also, would it be better to spend more on a graphics card with the $250 deal, or is the i3 more important than the graphics card?

Thanks for the help!


Message edited by J4211 on 01-13-2012 at 02:40:55 AM
Reply to J4211
Register or log in to remove.

The Core I3 is a faster processor for most things, but the AMD has better graphics for light gaming. I have both graphics and can tell you it is true.

 

Even though the i3 is a dual core, it is multi-threaded, so it acts like a quad core.

 

Best advice would be go with the i3 and if the Intel graphics are not enough, you could always add an inexpensive video card. You can look up your game(s) on this site to see what minimum video specs you need. http://www.systemrequirementslab.com/cyri/intro.aspx


Message edited by tlmck on 01-13-2012 at 01:43:30 PM
------------------------------ The power supply is the most important component in any computer. Without a good quality one, you usually wind up with a really expensive door stop.
Reply to tlmck

I agree with tlmck. The phenom cpu would easily be bogged down, and the graphics card is..not so good. That i3 with a 40-50 dollar card would be a much better choice.

Reply to stingstang

compare Amd is 3.5ghz intel 3.1ghz ,a =1000gb hdd i =750 ,ram a=4gb upgrade upto 16Gb i=6gb upgrade upto 8gb ,amd has better graphics for gaming intel so far, so buy amd and upgrade ram into 8gb u get better system value for ur money

------------------------------ CollerMaster Haf942 cabinet+silentprogold1200W,coller v10,Motherboard:Asus crosshair5,Amd fx8150,Radeon6970,Trancend axe ram8gb2000+,hp dvd r+w,Aoc e2239Fwt moniter.
Reply to hitechgowthaman

compare Amd is 3.5ghz intel 3.1ghz ,a =1000gb hdd i =750 ,ram a=4gb upgrade upto 16Gb i=6gb upgrade upto 8gb ,amd has better graphics for gaming intel so far, so buy amd and upgrade ram into 8gb u get better system value for ur money

------------------------------ CollerMaster Haf942 cabinet+silentprogold1200W,coller v10,Motherboard:Asus crosshair5,Amd fx8150,Radeon6970,Trancend axe ram8gb2000+,hp dvd r+w,Aoc e2239Fwt moniter.
Reply to hitechgowthaman

Balance money in ur hand

------------------------------ CollerMaster Haf942 cabinet+silentprogold1200W,coller v10,Motherboard:Asus crosshair5,Amd fx8150,Radeon6970,Trancend axe ram8gb2000+,hp dvd r+w,Aoc e2239Fwt moniter.
Reply to hitechgowthaman

Thanks for all the input! I've decided to go with the intel i3 as I think this pc will hold out better in the future. A cheap graphics card will also boost its gaming performance if I find it lacking. Thanks again!

Reply to J4211

You made the right choice, it's the far more powerful out of those 2 systems.

Reply to grumbledook

Hi, I would not touch any of them since :

1- refurbish only gives you 60 to 90 days warranty,
2- hp isnt's making any good quality computers these days
3- you have a bunch of low quality parts in there.

If you get one of them prepare to invest money in it soon.

Considering that I would get a computer with know parts in them at least.

Reply to dextermat

Well I have bought refurbished PCs in the past and they have worked really well for me. I'm also not too picky about the parts and if some higher quality graphics don't run top notch it shouldn't be too much of a nuisance to me. Thanks a lot for the advice though.

Reply to J4211
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Systems > Prebuilt > Which pc should I buy? Intel i3 2100 or amd Phenom II 521?
Go to:

There are 2088 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
$1700 MINI ITX BUILD
By geofelt, 59 minutes ago:

I am currently using a Q08 as a back up pc. I am considering converting it to a gaming...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts