5970 CF vs 6970 CF

[McSaggler]

Hello,

Currently my friend is offering one of two options to me for free (so in this scenario, ignore all costs):
2 5970 2GB (technically Quadfire, 2 GPU's a card)
2 6970 2GB

Which one should I go with? Currently I am gaming at 1920x1200 and plan to stick with this for a while. I cannot sell the cards when I get them (my friend is giving them to me and I would feel wrong selling them behind his back).

I know the 5970 is a dual GPU card so technically I would only get 1GB of RAM as opposed to the 6970 2GB RAM.

I have ample power/CPU to compensate possible power issues and bottlenecking.

 

[hellfire24]

6970 crossfire=Hell Yeah!!!! instead of 5970 quadfire.

 

[McSaggler]

6970 crossfire=Hell Yeah!!!! instead of 5970 quadfire.

Any particular reasoning behind this? I hear the scaling is bad on the 5970 but I also hear that its fixed. What about the video RAM?

 

[andrewcarr]

Two 5970 would be much faster but on second week on January the 7000 series comes out if you can wait.

 

[megamanx00]

Two 5970s would be faster when they work right. Even though the 5970 is already 2 yrs old two of them still represent an insane amount of power. If you want to go eyefinity two 5970s would be better, but and boy there are buts.

Many games only support or work well with two GPU crossfire so sometimes it will be like only one 5970 is active. Worst case is that the second 5970 actually has a negative impact on performance which can happen. In those situations two 6970s are faster. Considering you're also either going to use eyefinity or have a single 2560 X 1600 monitor the extra RAM in the 6970s will provide a smoother experience than the 1GB per GPU in the 5970s on more memory intensive games with all the details turned up. Also, because the 6970s are newer they get priority in hotfixes for crossfire support with older cards only being taken care of afterwards. The recent case with skyrim is an example, though I'm pretty sure even a single 5870 can handle it and I haven't bought it simply because I can wait for it to be cheaper

So if you want more raw power and can wait a bit after games come out for proper support and are willing to fiddle with settings to get things to work then go with the 5970s. They may have more issues going forward but when they do work properly you'll be glad you have them. If you want a more problem free solution and can sacrifice the raw power then go with the 6970s. The 6970s will also be better for your electric bill , but if it was me I'd probably get the 5970s.

 

[McSaggler]

Best answer selected by McSaggler.