What should my CPU Temperature be? i5-3570k

Yes, that's normal. Load temp should be around 60C, give or take a little.

i thought it should be lower than that... i have a Hyper 212 Evo installed and its running at level 10 (highest setting). did i install it incorrectly?

Well possibly but I doubt it. I'm water cooling and my idle temps are around 32C.

do you think adding fans to the front of the chassis to blow air into the case would help at all? i have the Antec Eleven Hundred

Well... depends more on your ambient temps than air flow. We're talking about idle temps here, the load is very very low.

If you're worried about temps, look at what matters - full load temps. Try running Prime95 or Intel Burn Test to see how good your cooling is.

i did and my temps hovered around 60-62 with Prime95. Is that acceptable?

At all stock settings that seems roughly right, maybe a tad high but that would also depend on your ambient temps

well, i am in Florida, and the heat and humidity especially during summer are no joke   . are there any setting i can manipulate to make the temps any lower without having it tamper with the actual heatsink fan? ultimately, i want to be able to safely overclock in the near future to >4.2ghz and i want to get the lowest temp possible without messing with settings first

Only thing you can really do is increase the fan speed. Assuming you have it plugged into the CPU FAN plug on the mobo, you should have an option in the BIOS somewhere to manipulate the fan profile/speeds. Refer to your User Manual if you can't find it.

well, everything is always on max speed. im thinking of buying a nice new thermal compound and replacing the one i used that came with the Hyper 212 evo but im not sure if its worth the trouble or risk

I have an i5 3570k OC @ 3.7 Ghz and on a full load it was around 53 degrees Celsius. This was using a Hyper 212 evo, stock thermal paste and an Antec 300 case with fans all on maxium. Hope this helps as a baseline.