Hi everyone
I'm part of a group which regularly hosts LAN Parties at our university. Usually we have been borrowing switches from the university's IT department: 24 or 48 ports high end managed switches (HP, Cisco or similar) which is in reserve for the main university network.
New head of IT -> we cannot borrow them any more... to much work for the IT-department.
So we will go ahead and purchase our own. We will not be bying 10x 24port switches (as we usually borrow) since each "table" usually has less than 10 people, so 24 ports will be a waste (but when you borrow them, what the heck).
So we are looking for some 8 and 16 port switches. They will be linked like this:
One "main switch" with 1Gbit on each port. One 8 or 16 port switch for each 10-12 person table which will link back to the main switch. The switches the users will eventually link to should probably just be 100Mbit on each port and maybe have a 1Gbit uplink port?
The reason why I'm asking which switches to buy and not just buying http://www.ebuyer.com/product/54225 or something is:
I've for many years attended a "professionally" hosted LAN party ($50 tickets). They use some 8 port D-Link consumer/home switches for their last tier and they break down all the time and needs replacing or restart. And I know from my home DSL Router (supplied by my ISP) that it simply cannot route traffic for 10 computers, even though it in principle should be able to route for an "unlimited number of computers". The same situation could apply for switches - buy some cheap $50 switch and it will crash on you if you really load it on all ports for extended periods of time. So that's why I'm not too keen on buying regular $50 home networking switches.
What do you guys think?
Best, Wuhtzu
I'm part of a group which regularly hosts LAN Parties at our university. Usually we have been borrowing switches from the university's IT department: 24 or 48 ports high end managed switches (HP, Cisco or similar) which is in reserve for the main university network.
New head of IT -> we cannot borrow them any more... to much work for the IT-department.
So we will go ahead and purchase our own. We will not be bying 10x 24port switches (as we usually borrow) since each "table" usually has less than 10 people, so 24 ports will be a waste (but when you borrow them, what the heck).
So we are looking for some 8 and 16 port switches. They will be linked like this:
One "main switch" with 1Gbit on each port. One 8 or 16 port switch for each 10-12 person table which will link back to the main switch. The switches the users will eventually link to should probably just be 100Mbit on each port and maybe have a 1Gbit uplink port?
The reason why I'm asking which switches to buy and not just buying http://www.ebuyer.com/product/54225 or something is:
I've for many years attended a "professionally" hosted LAN party ($50 tickets). They use some 8 port D-Link consumer/home switches for their last tier and they break down all the time and needs replacing or restart. And I know from my home DSL Router (supplied by my ISP) that it simply cannot route traffic for 10 computers, even though it in principle should be able to route for an "unlimited number of computers". The same situation could apply for switches - buy some cheap $50 switch and it will crash on you if you really load it on all ports for extended periods of time. So that's why I'm not too keen on buying regular $50 home networking switches.
What do you guys think?
Best, Wuhtzu