Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Static on Audio CD's - help please

Last response: in Storage
Share
Anonymous
a b G Storage
July 18, 2001 3:40:20 PM

My daughter has reported a problem when burning audio CD's on her computer (she has successfully burned dozens on my machine) - when she plays them, there is static noise on the recording. The source MP3's play fine on the computer, and she gets the static whether she plays the CD's on a regular stereo or on the computer. The system is a PII -400, 128 Meg ram, Intel 440BX motherboard, Creative 8x4x32(?) CD-RW, and Nero software. Hard drive is primary master, CD-rw is secondary master. Have tried different brands of CD-R's as well. Any thoughts?

Thanks

Rich

More about : static audio

July 18, 2001 3:53:02 PM

What speed does she burn at??
Maybe a lower speed would help.

<font color=blue>Your mouse moved. WINDOWS NT must restart for changes to take affect. Restart Now?[OK]</font color=blue>
July 20, 2001 1:25:26 PM

have you tried using diffrent decoders for the mp3

the one i found for free that works pretty good is mpegdj gowave

<font color=red>Gasoline + Fire</font color=red><font color=green> Can be a lot of fun</font color=green> :smile: :smile: :smile:
Related resources
July 20, 2001 2:55:09 PM

Not sure if this is the answer to your problem, but it could be the new form of copy protection. Does it happen with old CD's as well as newer ones? Here is the article from cnet:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
For the last several months, consumers in ordinary record stores around the world have unwittingly been buying CDs that include technology designed to discourage them from making copies on their PCs.

According to Macrovision, the company that has provided the technology to several major music labels, the test has been going on for four to six months. Although it's not disclosing just which titles have been loaded with the technology, at least one has sold close to 100,000 copies, the company said.

The technology, which inserts audible clicks and pops into music files that are copied from a CD onto a PC, highlights what could become a critical part of the major music labels' efforts to stem digital piracy.

Although the labels can do little to stop consumers from "ripping," or digitally copying, the hundreds of millions of old CDs already on the market, they are looking for ways to protect new releases, which constitute the bulk of their annual sales.

But the tests also take aim at the basic consumer practice of copying CDs to a computer for personal use without ever trading the songs with others. Although this is a familiar--and legally protected--task in the world of cassette tapes, the legality of creating music collections on a personal computer is more cloudy.

If the Macrovision tests prove successful and the technology is widely adopted, the ability to create personal music collections on PCs, or to create mixed CDs from purchased CDs, may significantly diminish. Analysts say this is particularly likely if the labels finally start selling protected downloads online.

"I do see this as the future if labels have gone down the path of secure digital downloads," said P.J. McNealy, an analyst with GartnerG2. "But I would be surprised that the labels would not communicate this to consumers."

Clicks and pops
Record companies have toyed with protecting CDs against copying for several years. But the technology is a difficult one, because anything added to a CD risks degrading the sound on an ordinary CD player to the point where audiophiles--or even ordinary consumers--start complaining.

Previous efforts have largely foundered. A BMG Music trial in Germany was scrapped after many consumers said the copy-protected discs would not play on their CD players. An album release by country artist Charley Pride earlier this year misfired when unprotected versions were released in some markets, allowing songs from the CD to seep onto file-swapping networks.

The most high-profile effort, the cross-industry Secure Digital Music Initiative (SDMI), has all but scrapped its plans to add digital "watermarks" to recorded music, after disagreements between labels, consumer device manufacturers and technology companies derailed the effort.

The Macrovision tests are based on a technology acquired from Israeli company TTR Technologies. Rather than blocking copying altogether, the technology introduces some digital distortion into a file. Macrovision says this is all but inaudible when a CD is played through an ordinary CD player, but when a song is copied into digital format on a PC's hard drive, the distortion shows up as annoying "clicks and pops" in the music.

The company said it and the labels are in large part testing to see if the changes in the audio are audible to consumers. Reports so far have turned up no significantly higher number of CD returns or consumer complaints, a spokeswoman said.

The company would not say which CDs or labels have been involved, citing nondisclosure agreements with the music labels.

"They don't want to influence the listener's potential experience," said Macrovision spokeswoman Miao Chang.

BMG Entertainment confirmed that it was interested in the technology but stopped short of confirming that any of its CDs in the market include the copy protection.

"BMG is interested in copy-management technology, and we will be conducting tests on some available technology including Macrovision," a BMG spokesman said.

Other major labels would not immediately comment on the issue.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
July 20, 2001 3:26:19 PM

No, that wouldn't cause static, just wouldn't copy correctly.
Thanks for the article, though.

-----------------
Whoever thinks up a good sig for me gets a prize :wink:
July 24, 2001 5:37:13 AM

hmmm...
thats nasty

not to mention somewhat dubious legally
what if i were to rip my music so i could play it on my portable slash ram mp3 player?
i baught the cd legally, as with the player, and are not distributing it to anyone else. tell me where the illegality is?

im suprised someone hasnt brought that up legally.


"i love the smell of Overclocking in the morning!" Says my Hamster.
July 24, 2001 6:58:33 PM

Do you really think they're going to come up with something that isn't easily cracked? Doubt it.

-----------------
Whoever thinks up a good sig for me gets a prize :wink:
July 24, 2001 11:10:43 PM

How this for a Hack.
using my normal cd player i take the optical out in to my sound card. rips cd in pure digital. cant find a cd with protection to try it on yet though. as to the hiss it could be a crap sound card. or bad electro magnetic interference.
!