Most cases are fairly generic with some sporting different features to others. For the size of your components, you'd probably be good looking at a coolermaster. Perhaps a CM 690 II, which is a mid-size case (still much larger than most commercially available pre-built designs though). Try getting one though with USB 3.0 (CM 690 II Advanced) for the newer cpu.
A lot of it comes down to preference though, I just think this case is common and known to be cheaper, yet high quality.
Thanks everyone for the cases.
With the GPU, my 6870's fan seized up, and I'm waiting for XFX to get back to me on a possible RMA, but of course It has to break on Thanksgiving in the US, so their support team is most likely out of office.
So this really comes down to more of a preference and price point kind of situation.