Looking to build a small PC and really intrested in building a ITX. So lets get to it!
Reason: Able to play MAX settings on WoW, D3, GW2 @ 1920x1080 via HDMI (surfing internet, streaming media, etc -not all at once)
Preferred: Local pickup @ www.canadacomputers.com or tigerdirect.ca
Location: Toronto Ontario
Parts Preferences: Don't matter but I do pefer Nivida as the GPU but really..doesn't matter
Overclocking: Yes if its worth it. (Not benchmarking, just want to play games smoothly)
SLI or Crossfire: No
Your Monitor Resolution: 1920x1080 46inch LCD TV
Additional Comments: Would love low noise and Less heat the better
Not needed: Monitor, OS, mouse, Keyboard.
Price: $800.00 or less. I could go up to $1000.00 but only if its a really big difference.
Note: The mobo I choose at this time is a H77 -a non OC-ing mobo.
Need advice on:
1) Any changes to the build -any savings found?
4) is AMD a viable option?
I'd suggest an Intel i3 CPU. AMD is viable as a CPU, but with an ITX system, you probably want to keep heat to an absolute minimum and AMD simply doesn't do that too well right now.
For graphics, AMD is a very viable option. You could go for a Radeon 7850 if it would fit in your case, but I'm not sure. A Radeon 7770 should be able to handle 1080p with some settings reduced in today's more intense games and should fit in your case no problem. We'd have to check the dimensions to find out what would and wouldn't fit.
I would argue with the above poster about the recommendation of an i3 CPU for an i5-3450.
However, I do agree about the recommendation of an HD7850 if it will fit in the Prodigy (I would imagine it would fit though). Though, if you were to go for an HD7770, I would HIGHLY recommend the HD6870 instead. It's last gen, but it'll perform better than the HD7770. http://www.hwcompare.com/11924/radeon-hd-6870-vs-radeon...
AMD would technically work but generally their CPU's need to be overclocked to be good for gaming. Overclocking definitely wouldn't be recommended for a mini ITX system.
I would go for:
Intel Core i3-2120
H77 Mini ITX Motherboard
2x4GB 1333Mhz RAM
Sapphire Ultimate HD 7750 (Passive)
Crucial M4 128GB
380W Seasonic PSU
Scythe Shuriken CPU Cooler
That would be cheap and should play all of those games on ultra high settings really. You wouldn't get ultra high on more demanding games but this would be ultra quiet.
If you can cope with a bit more noise and something a tad more expensive, you could swap:
i3-2120 for i5-3450
HD 7750 for HD 7850
380W Seasonic for 430W Seasonic (Their PSU's tend to be incredibly quiet.)
That one should play pretty much anything at ultra high settings and be just a bit more noisy. Still quiet though so long as you get a good HD 7850 like the higher end ASUS or MSI ones. I think Sapphire are good too.
A lower wattage PSU would save you more money which you could invest in other components. And if overclocking is out of the questions, you don't need more than around ~400w
However, considering the price of the Seasonic PSU's, wouldn't it be a better option to go with a PSU from a different brand? I imagine something from the Corsair CX Series of PSU's to be a viable option. They aren't very loud from personal experience as well.
i3 or i5, wouldn't make much difference in most games with these graphics cards and even in games that it might, it still wouldn't be a huge difference. If you want a faster CPU, then the i5-3450 is a great option.
Overclocking could change this with the 7850 because it has a lot of headroom that the i3s simply can't handle in every game, but overclocking doesn't seem like something you'd do.
The i5 is easily the more future-proofed option for several reasons and I'd prefer it with the 7850, but I wouldn't build an ITX machine for myself and I'd overclock it very far, so I didn't think that my opinion on that sort of thing would be unbiased enough.
I would argue about ITX builds and overclocking, however, as the Bitfenix Prodigy case OP has selected proved to be a very nice ITX case...
However, that's beside the point. I would still prefer the i5 3450 IF you could get the HD7850/HD6870. If meaning getting the i5 would compromise on the GPU...for example, not enough budget and you have to drop down to an HD7770, then go for an i3+7850 combination by all means.
If you can still squeeze in both the i5 3450 AND a Radeon HD7850, then this would be the path I would take.
Another slightly more unorthodox option would be to get the i5 build but replace the i5 with a Pentium G620. It is extremely cheap and performs the same as an FX-4100 in games. It's not even that far behind the i3, you would be surprised. Then just get along with that for a bit till you can afford the i5-3450.
Even the FX-4100 kicks the crap out of a Pentium in any well-threaded CPU-bound game. Even the i3 can hold a roughly up to 30% lead over it in such games and an i5 can be more than twice as fast. The Pentiums are great for games that don't rely on the CPU too much, but they kinda suck for very CPU-bound games. BF3 MP with 32-64 players might bring a Pentium to its knees.
Yeah I'm just saying maybe use it for 6 months or something till he can afford the i5. The Pentium would cope fine with GW2, WoW and D3 I imagine. I agree that it might struggle in larger maps on games like BF3.