Rosewill Blackhawk front panel headphone jack seated too low?

Hi everyone,

I just recently put together my first build and it went well and I've been using this sweet computer for a while without any problems. I just tried to plug in headphones for the first time into my Rosewill Blackhawk case and had some problems.. first of all, I was only getting sound out of the left can (nothing wrong when I use my phone or ipod or whatever), secondly I was getting sound from my normal speakers as well. I unplugged the phones and plugged them back in and noticed this little pop up that says headphones plugged in, but almost immediately another pop up says headphones unplugged. This happens every time. If I plug them in and press down and hold it there, the message doesn't come up saying they were unplugged, but if I relieve any pressure and stop holding them there it they "unplug". I'm pretty sure the jack is screwed up (or...jacked up, I might say) and maybe seated too low into the front panel so the headphone plugs aren't quite reaching all the way, but if anyone thinks it's something otherwise I'm all ears.

I'm wondering what I can do, though, if the jack is screwed up? I really don't want to have to take the whole computer apart and send the case back or whatever...I dunno what I'd even do with all the parts in the meantime... Anyone have any ideas for me to fix myself perhaps?