ckholt83 said:
I hate arguing with fanboys.
I am not partial to either AMD or Intel as a company, I've built many systems using both brands over the years for different purposes. The simple truth is that right now Intel CPUs trounce AMD for gaming. He's got room in the budget for it, it's silly not to.
Here is a direct comparison between an i5 3450 and a $100 Phenom II x4:
http://www.cpu-world.com/Compare/822/AMD_Phenom_II_X4_9...(140W__BE)_vs_Intel_Core_i5_i5-3450.html
(note that the 'positive' direction varies for some benchmarks)
Also of note is the Tomshardware gaming CPU buyer's guide, just updated this week:
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/gaming-cpu-review-o...
Notice how the Phenom II x4 is not recommended at any price point. Also take a look at hierarchy on the last page and notice that the it 3450 is in the top tier, whereas a $100 phenom II x4 is in the 4th.
Take a look at the data and decide for yourself.
while i do prefer amd over intel i alway gives reasons for someone to get either but i would only get intel if im gonna do video editing cause for GAMING you dont need that speed (it will help) i never said YOU MUST GET AMD i said if you want to spend 100 more dollars go for it i also said many times intel IS better than amd but for GAMING purposes there really isnt a need to spend 100 extra dollars unless of course you want to.
also this will sound ignorant but i dont care for and usually dont trust a lot of benchmarks
reason for not caring
benchmarks stress the entire cpu but i only use my pc for casual or gaming why do i need it to render in 5 seconds when for half the price it can render in 20 seconds but still do the same things gaming wise
reason for not trusting benchmarks
i have looked at them a lot and i used to trust them a lot then i got the fx 6100 and saw that most benchmarks showed it not being able to play starcraft 2 or even world of warcraft but mine plays those games fine at 60fps no dips
if you look at a performance for the price, so the lowest priced cpu that still performs good
as much as i hate benchmarks this site seems to usually be close and this is a benchmark/price comparison
http://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_lookup.php?cpu=AMD+Phen...
as you can see FOR THE PRICE you cant really beat amd
but as you said OP has some room in the budget i just said what i would probably do but im all about saving money
edit: to get to the chart i was talking about you need to scroll to the top and click price performance