leviwilner :
Whoah! Seriously! It was worth $350 back in the day!!
I think you're thinking of 9800gtx(+), not 9800gt
leviwilner :
So basically anything that I am going to get for $100+ will have better performance than what I currently have??!?!
Not exactly. Something like an HD6750 or 7750 wouldn't be much of an upgrade for you.
If you are concerned about thermals, get a dual slot card with a blower fan that vents
hot air out the back of your case.
Some of the best options in your price range right now are HD7770 and gtx550ti.
This is whether you are in Canada or the US. (based on prices at Newegg)
The gtx550ti is about the same tdp as 9800gt, HD7770 is much lower. Not that you should
be concerned about that with your 500w ocz psu, though.
I know you said you were not overclocking. Both of these video cards can be OCed by a
fair amount to get you more performance for free(the 7770 more so than gtx550ti).
Your mobo is good at overclocking. Depending on your processor and ram you may be
able to overclock your cpu. You could maybe do some with a stock intel cooler, or use
some money left over from buying a HD7770 or gtx550ti well under 150 and get a
decent aftermarket cpu cooler like a hyper 212 +/evo. You definitely don't want your
cpu to bottleneck a new gpu.
Also, you really should check in with EVGA to see if maybe they will give you a replacement
graphics card free of charge. I think that based on the model and the timeframe it was
prevalent it may well have a lifetime warranty if you registered it in a timely fashion.