Plugged in a new DVI monitor and replaced the VGA one and now when I open the nvidia settings and go to "Adjust image settings with preview" I get about 15 "Microsoft Visual C++ Runtime Library Errors" saying CRT not initialized. I was using the latest beta drivers, so I thought "Maybe just a bad drivers setting or something?" and completely uninstalled the drivers and re-installed the latest stable drivers from disc and I'm still experiencing it.
I searched around and found a few posts saying installing the Visual C++ redistributables helps, but I've already installed both the x86 and x64 versions of 2005, 2008, and 2010. My bios is also up to date.