Looking for a basic graphics card

My CPU is an old E5400 2.7GHZ. I bought a 7850 XFX Core Edition and it coil whined really bad. I asked for a refund instead of a replacement. I rarely game on my desktop since I mainly play console games. I have a 9600gt 1GB card in my system right now. I bought the 7850 because it was cheap. Should I ask for a replacement or get a card that won't bottleneck my system too bad. Honestly, I couldn't notice the bottleneck in my computer with the 7850 since I don't hardly game at all. If the 7850 is not an option should I look for a 7770, 650, or a 650ti. My price range is below $140. Also, my power supply is an XFX 450W Core Edition that didn't have any trouble handling the 7850 that only had one 6pin connector.