I don't think either of those are very good deals. But the Newegg one is better. If you are gonna spend $440 on a 680, minght as well spend $10 more to get a 7970 ghz which is a tier higher on the tomshardware hierarchy. Also 7970 ghz come with three games. So I would check out that card as well to see which on you want more.
You could also look at getting a 7970 non ghz because those are about as strong as a 680. Also the 670 is a better value than a 680.
I already placed the order for the gtx 680, and the deal for the games for AMD has ended already, so I figure I could trade Assassins Creed 3 for Far Cry 3, I already own Sleeping Dogs, and I would rather wait on Absolution.
Thank you for the advice but, I believe I have 30 days before my ability to refund returns, and if the gtx 680 isn't doing right for me, I can return it. I also figured that EVGA has great support, and although AMD just released the Never Settle drivers, most of the games I play seem to be backed by Nvidia right out of the gate.
This being my first build, and already having owned an AMD card, I'm still learning some things, so if Nvidia turns out to be a joke, I plan on doing other builds in the future.