Ahh ok, Well if you could double your budget, You could get a nice video card. Although the ones you listed are affordable, They won't give you what you desire, if you want a video card for gaming... You will be running low FPS and it will not last very long as in years wise. If you where to increase your budget to about $240, You could get a Radeon 7870, and have a video card that will last the next 3-4 years of gaming. If you buy one of the cards you listed, It will be expired by 2014.