Sudoku: strategy for generating boards?
Anonymous
Archived from groups: comp.ai.games (More info?)
I'm trying to generate Sudoku boards. I'm not looking for a full
solution; I'm looking for a nudge in the right direction (i.e. is this
a graph/pathfinding problem that is easily modeled and addressed in
theory, etc.). If you don't know what Sudoku is, it's a game played on
a 9x9 grid, with 9 3x3 subgrids. Each square can hold a numerical
value between 19. The goal is to fill in each square according to
these rules:
 each 9column row cannot have duplicate numbers
 each 9row column cannot have duplicate numbers
 each 3x3 subgrid cannot have duplicate numbers within themselves
At the beginning of each game, you as the player are presented with a
board which has some squares already filled in with valid values.
For more information, please check the Wikipedia.
Okay, so I'm trying to figure out an algorithm for generating Sudoku
boards, using random numbers where possible (i.e. a "random" board). I
tried brute forcing it, but there were complications such that I feel a
pathfinding (or similar) search is required. I don't know a lot about
AI, but I had a course in it, so I know the basics. I feel like I
should be able to represent the board with a graph, and at the moment
I'm thinking that might look like: each node connected to each node in
its 3x3 subgrid, and each node connected to each node in its row and
column. Beyond this, I'm not really sure how to go about searching
such a graph (or whatever the "correct" graph might look like, assuming
this method of solution is appropriate). Specifically, I'm not sure
how to recover if I get into a situation that requires regressing back
to a nonobvious state. For example, if you just go through each node,
starting at row 0, col 0, and moving right, by the time you get to the
second row, in the last subgrid you can achieve deadlock  no valid
numbers available (no valid "moves" available?). At this point, it
seems like I'd have to back up, but I have no idea how far I should
back up. Should I back up one level at a time, until things work? I
really don't know how to approach this. I feel as though any general
finger pointing in the right direction would help me immensely. Thank
you very much.
 Sean
I'm trying to generate Sudoku boards. I'm not looking for a full
solution; I'm looking for a nudge in the right direction (i.e. is this
a graph/pathfinding problem that is easily modeled and addressed in
theory, etc.). If you don't know what Sudoku is, it's a game played on
a 9x9 grid, with 9 3x3 subgrids. Each square can hold a numerical
value between 19. The goal is to fill in each square according to
these rules:
 each 9column row cannot have duplicate numbers
 each 9row column cannot have duplicate numbers
 each 3x3 subgrid cannot have duplicate numbers within themselves
At the beginning of each game, you as the player are presented with a
board which has some squares already filled in with valid values.
For more information, please check the Wikipedia.
Okay, so I'm trying to figure out an algorithm for generating Sudoku
boards, using random numbers where possible (i.e. a "random" board). I
tried brute forcing it, but there were complications such that I feel a
pathfinding (or similar) search is required. I don't know a lot about
AI, but I had a course in it, so I know the basics. I feel like I
should be able to represent the board with a graph, and at the moment
I'm thinking that might look like: each node connected to each node in
its 3x3 subgrid, and each node connected to each node in its row and
column. Beyond this, I'm not really sure how to go about searching
such a graph (or whatever the "correct" graph might look like, assuming
this method of solution is appropriate). Specifically, I'm not sure
how to recover if I get into a situation that requires regressing back
to a nonobvious state. For example, if you just go through each node,
starting at row 0, col 0, and moving right, by the time you get to the
second row, in the last subgrid you can achieve deadlock  no valid
numbers available (no valid "moves" available?). At this point, it
seems like I'd have to back up, but I have no idea how far I should
back up. Should I back up one level at a time, until things work? I
really don't know how to approach this. I feel as though any general
finger pointing in the right direction would help me immensely. Thank
you very much.
 Sean
2
answers
Last reply
More about sudoku strategy generating boards

Archived from groups: comp.ai.games (More info?)
sean.gilbertson@gmail.com wrote in news:1114548199.302504.115850
@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com:
> I'm trying to generate Sudoku boards. I'm not looking for a full
> solution; I'm looking for a nudge in the right direction (i.e. is this
> a graph/pathfinding problem that is easily modeled and addressed in
> theory, etc.).
There's a thread about Sudoku right now on rec.puzzles. Thread name is "Su
Doku", and gcrhoads describes a way to formulate Sudoku as an exact cover
problem. It may be helpful to you.
Beyond that, maybe start constructing simpler versions of the puzzle, like,
say, 3x3 boards with no subgrids. Once you can do those, try 4x4 boards
with 2x2 subgrids. Those will have less complexity, and may reveal
properties and techniques useful for constructing larger puzzles. 
Archived from groups: comp.ai.games (More info?)
Hi,
I think there is no need to have such a complex data structure as
you have described. All you need is a 9x9 array of integers to
represent the board. You an initialize the board by assigning zero
value to all the elements suggesting that the board is empty. Now as
you said, lets assume that you want to make a board where "N"
random board positions are occupied (in accordance to all the rules).
You can start with first randomly selecting the board positions that
will be filled, and saving the locations (a 2 dimensional array of
length "N" will do it). Now we will try to assign random values
(between 1 and 9) to this selected location and select one (or all) of
the locations that are consistent with the rules of the game. Thus you
have "9^N" possible board positions to search from. The search
space can be though of as a tree structure where the root node is an
empty board. The next level will be the nine possible state of the
board when we try to populate the first position of the board from the
list of randomly selected board positions. The 2nd level of the tree
will be all the possible state of the board with the first two randomly
selected positions are filled. You can do a DFS search by a recursive
function that take a current board position, the list of random board
positions to be filled and N. The function will try to populate the
appropriate board position and check if it is consistent with the
rules. When it finds such a board position, it will change the board to
reflect the changes and call function recursively. If the function
finds that all the positions it can generate (9 in total) are
inconsistent with the rules, then it's a deadlock and the function
returns with a failure. The function will also have to keep track of
what values when assigned to the board resulted in the recursive call
called in failure so at to not to try same value again which had
resulted in failure before.
int** generate_random(int board[][9], locations_to_be_filled[][2], int
N, int current_location);
Here the board state is stored in board[9][9], "N" is the number of
board positions to be filled, where locations are stored in
locations_to_be_filled. For example lets say we want to generate a
board with three positions been filled and we randomly select the
positions to be top left corner, bottom right corner and center, then N
will be 3 and locations to be filled will be { 0,0},{4,4},{8,8}.
Hope this helps,
Bhavesh Goswami
Ask a new question
Read More
Games
Video Games
Related Resources
 Alphabeta search frustrations
 Sudoku generator
 [ANN] Sudoku 0.0.4 is released
 ADOM article on Wikipedia
 Old strategy game
 Depth of Search
 "Search" under Mindslaver
 Info on the A* algorithm
 Set algorithm
 MAME in Wikipedia
 New player strategy.
 Wikipedia
 Which are the most commonly used algorithms for fiveina..
 Modified Eller's Algorithm
 Chess ai
 Invalid serial number for cammand and conquer the first decade
 The $17,500 video game
 What is the best singleplayer strategy game right now?
 Better than wikipedia