I am in the process of buying a new case for my computer. Since there is not much to choose from in our computer stores, I will probably get a <b>Chieftec Dragon DA-01SLD</b> full tower case. I can also get a smaller but aluminum <b>Chieftec Dragon AX-01SLD</b> mid tower case. Right now I don’t really need all 6 of the 5,25” slots in the full tower, but I would like to have them as an option for the future, and I really like the sheer volume of space in a full tower . So, is there any good reason to go with the smaller aluminum case? Is aluminum all that it's cracked up to be (releasing heat 3 times faster and so on)? I would like to stress out that I am not concerned about the smaller weight, or the (arguable?) better looks of aluminum cases.
--- <i>Part of the price you must pay for any knowledge is to discover it for yourself.</i> ---
I just bought a aluminum Dragon series myself. I haven't put my system in it yet so I don't know about the thermal hype, but as far as weight goes it <i>is</i> light. Compared to my steel case it feals like a toy. It's not quite as sturdy, but it's not bad. I'll have to see what happens as far as temps.
Oh, and they look exactly the same as steel cases except the bare metal is shiney rather then dull. Unless you have a window, it really doesn't matter.
There is much thermal 'hype' about aluminium cases. I dont believe any of them. All of the components within the case are well isolated by a lot of air. The last millimeter out to the open surroundings does not affect internal temperature regardless of the material. Compared to air, both iron and aluminium are both extremely good heat conductors. The relatively small difference between iron and aluminium is not significant.
That is exactly what I was thinking about. Since I’m buying this case for a longer period I wanted to be sure that I’m not missing out on something if I don’t go with aluminum. Anyway, when I load up the case with all the fans it can take , there shouldn’t be any problems with heath dissipation.
--- <i>Part of the price you must pay for any knowledge is to discover it for yourself.</i> ---
No, the thermal hype is about alu cases being better. So at least it should be as good as an iron case. But the actual location of venting holes and their size has a much larger influence than the material of the case. So if you are unlucky and the alu case is not well contructed regarding airflow, you may be better off with a good iron case.
<i><b>Beware of any philosophy that will fit in this space</b></i>
Yeah, I'm afraid I couldn't share anything about the temps. :\ Still, it's nice not straining your back when you go to move the thing.
Newegg has nice prices on Dragon style cases. I got a blue one with a window from them, simply because I like blue(and I don't own a Dremel). Specialty cases <A HREF="http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProduct.asp?submit=manufactory&catalog=304&manufactory=1651&DEPA=1&sortby=14&order=1" target="_new">here</A>.
I wonder what the difference would be? Assuming one could find 2 cases made exactly the same way.
Given that aluminium IS a better conductor it should be slightly better, but air has to circulate within the case for the actual case to act like a big passive heatsink, so a single low speed exhaust fan could probably do far more.
Im going to upgrade from steel to aluminium in a month or so, so we shall see. With normal running the steel gets slightly warm.
<b>And if you gaze for long into Toms Hardware Forums, The Forum gazes also into you! </b>
I did some research on the net, and what I found were a lot of articles mentioning the temperature decrease in aluminum cases, BUT those reviews were very sloppy. They use an ordinary iron case with one, maybe two ordinary fans and then switch to an aluminum case with 4 or more high flow fans. Well, of course the temperatures drop slightly . Then there is also the other <A HREF="http://www.procooling.com/articles/html/5_myths_about_cooling__-_phaes.shtml" target="_new"> side</A> which claims that the whole theory of aluminum cases acting as giant heatsinks is ridiculous. Well, after some consideration, I think that if a man doesn’t move his case a lot, and doesn’t need/like the aluminum look, he can do just fine with a smartly built iron case.
--- <i>Part of the price you must pay for any knowledge is to discover it for yourself.</i> ---
You plan to keep your system a long time. The Steel case is MUCH sturdier. Should you have an accident, like smaking it with the trash can (hey, some people put the things under their desks), you're less likely to leave dents. If you accidently drop it while moving, you're less likely to twist the case enough to damage it or the board.
<font color=blue>You're posting in a forum with class. It may be third class, but it's still class!</font color=blue>
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months. If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.