Tom's Hardware > Forum > Smartphones & PDAs > Palmpilot > Need better serial data connection to Palm

Need better serial data connection to Palm

Forum Smartphones & PDAs : Palmpilot - Need better serial data connection to Palm

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

I have a Tungsten T2 running Mapopolis Navigator with their maps. It
has a GPS mode where it receives continuous position updates from an
external GPS receiver and plots your location on the map, scrolling the
map as necessary. I've had all this working using the standard data
cable for the GPS receiver, a serial hotsync cable for the Palm, and a
3-wire male-male null modem cable.

However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps
popping in and out of tracking. I think the problem is where the serial
hotsync cable connects to the "universal connector" on the T2. This has
got to be the worst design of connector I've ever seen for field use;
nothing holds it together, or even holds the connector in the correct
orientation to the Palm. There are no pins and sockets to connect each
circuit; just a row of spring-loaded fingers and contact pads. I can
see that it would work reasonably well in the charging stand, where the
Palm is held at a fixed angle, but as a way of maintaining a connection
on a portable/mobile piece of equipment it's just plain poor design.

Is there any solution to this? I suppose I could just get a serial
hotsync cradle, and use something like a rubber band to keep the Palm in
the cradle despite bumps in the car. Or is it possible to convert the
serial NMEA data stream to infrared pulses in a format that the Palm's
IR receiver can handle?

Yes, I know I could buy a Bluetooth GPS receiver, but that's expensive
and I don't want to buy another receiver. I want to use one of the ones
I have.

Dave

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

Does the T2 have Bluetooth? If so buy a Bluetooth receiver.

Richard

"Dave Martindale" <davem@cs.ubc.ca> wrote in message
news:c8ofpm$619$2@mughi.cs.ubc.ca...
> I have a Tungsten T2 running Mapopolis Navigator with their maps. It
> has a GPS mode where it receives continuous position updates from an
> external GPS receiver and plots your location on the map, scrolling the
> map as necessary. I've had all this working using the standard data
> cable for the GPS receiver, a serial hotsync cable for the Palm, and a
> 3-wire male-male null modem cable.
>
> However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps
> popping in and out of tracking. I think the problem is where the serial
> hotsync cable connects to the "universal connector" on the T2. This has
> got to be the worst design of connector I've ever seen for field use;
> nothing holds it together, or even holds the connector in the correct
> orientation to the Palm. There are no pins and sockets to connect each
> circuit; just a row of spring-loaded fingers and contact pads. I can
> see that it would work reasonably well in the charging stand, where the
> Palm is held at a fixed angle, but as a way of maintaining a connection
> on a portable/mobile piece of equipment it's just plain poor design.
>
> Is there any solution to this? I suppose I could just get a serial
> hotsync cradle, and use something like a rubber band to keep the Palm in
> the cradle despite bumps in the car. Or is it possible to convert the
> serial NMEA data stream to infrared pulses in a format that the Palm's
> IR receiver can handle?
>
> Yes, I know I could buy a Bluetooth GPS receiver, but that's expensive
> and I don't want to buy another receiver. I want to use one of the ones
> I have.
>
> Dave

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

"Middle aged" <spam@rogers.spam> writes:
>Does the T2 have Bluetooth? If so buy a Bluetooth receiver.

Yes, it does have Bluetooth. But the last paragraph of my original
article said:

>> Yes, I know I could buy a Bluetooth GPS receiver, but that's expensive
>> and I don't want to buy another receiver. I want to use one of the ones
>> I have.

Dave

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

"Dave Martindale" <davem@cs.ubc.ca> wrote in message
news:c8ofpm$619$2@mughi.cs.ubc.ca...
> I have a Tungsten T2 running Mapopolis Navigator with their maps. It
> has a GPS mode where it receives continuous position updates from an
> external GPS receiver and plots your location on the map, scrolling the
> map as necessary. I've had all this working using the standard data
> cable for the GPS receiver, a serial hotsync cable for the Palm, and a
> 3-wire male-male null modem cable.
>
> However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps
> popping in and out of tracking. I think the problem is where the serial
> hotsync cable connects to the "universal connector" on the T2. This has
> got to be the worst design of connector I've ever seen for field use;
> nothing holds it together, or even holds the connector in the correct
> orientation to the Palm. There are no pins and sockets to connect each
> circuit; just a row of spring-loaded fingers and contact pads. I can
> see that it would work reasonably well in the charging stand, where the
> Palm is held at a fixed angle, but as a way of maintaining a connection
> on a portable/mobile piece of equipment it's just plain poor design.
>

All universal connectors are not equal. The most stable one I have is the
one sold by Gomadic for Palm to Phone cable combos. On the other hand, the
one sold by Gomadic as a DIY UC is not stable at all and easily breaks. The
advantage of the one mentioned first is that it has a dorsal plate touching
the palm chassis which supports the connector and makes it less prone to
move. You can further reinforce the junction with tape. I tried it now on a
Tungsten T. Quite good fit. You could even glue a longer rigid support to
the plate that goes further up the back of the Palm and hold it down with a
rubber band situated over the row of buttons.

If you want this connector, you probably have to buy a whole cable combo
(www.gomadic.com)

Inside the connector all contacts are available for soldering. The inhouse
resistor determining serial/modem function is 99 kohms.

Maybe Gomadic would sell only this connector to you. Would be interesting to
know. iQue users are also interested.


Jonas Lonnroth
Brussels

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

"Jonas Lonnroth" <ispe_nospam@skynet.be> writes:

>All universal connectors are not equal. The most stable one I have is the
>one sold by Gomadic for Palm to Phone cable combos. On the other hand, the
>one sold by Gomadic as a DIY UC is not stable at all and easily breaks. The
>advantage of the one mentioned first is that it has a dorsal plate touching
>the palm chassis which supports the connector and makes it less prone to
>move. You can further reinforce the junction with tape. I tried it now on a
>Tungsten T. Quite good fit. You could even glue a longer rigid support to
>the plate that goes further up the back of the Palm and hold it down with a
>rubber band situated over the row of buttons.

That suggests an interesting experiment: clamping my existing connector
to a plate that the Palm then rests on. This would be sort of like a
homemade docking stand, but flat rather than triangular so the Palm lies
down.

The hotsync cable I have does work when the connection to the Palm is
prevented from flexing. Maybe I need to be more agressive about holding
things rigidly in place.

Dave

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

If the T2 uses the universal connector there are some good serial cables
out there. check with supplynet or pc-mobile.

Dale

Dave Martindale wrote:

> I have a Tungsten T2 running Mapopolis Navigator with their maps. It
> has a GPS mode where it receives continuous position updates from an
> external GPS receiver and plots your location on the map, scrolling the
> map as necessary. I've had all this working using the standard data
> cable for the GPS receiver, a serial hotsync cable for the Palm, and a
> 3-wire male-male null modem cable.
>
> However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps
> popping in and out of tracking. I think the problem is where the serial
> hotsync cable connects to the "universal connector" on the T2. This has
> got to be the worst design of connector I've ever seen for field use;
> nothing holds it together, or even holds the connector in the correct
> orientation to the Palm. There are no pins and sockets to connect each
> circuit; just a row of spring-loaded fingers and contact pads. I can
> see that it would work reasonably well in the charging stand, where the
> Palm is held at a fixed angle, but as a way of maintaining a connection
> on a portable/mobile piece of equipment it's just plain poor design.
>
> Is there any solution to this? I suppose I could just get a serial
> hotsync cradle, and use something like a rubber band to keep the Palm in
> the cradle despite bumps in the car. Or is it possible to convert the
> serial NMEA data stream to infrared pulses in a format that the Palm's
> IR receiver can handle?
>
> Yes, I know I could buy a Bluetooth GPS receiver, but that's expensive
> and I don't want to buy another receiver. I want to use one of the ones
> I have.
>
> Dave

--
_ _ Dale DePriest
/`) _ // http://users.cwnet.com/dalede
o/_/ (_(_X_(` For GPS and GPS/PDAs

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

davem@cs.ubc.ca (Dave Martindale) wrote in news:c8ofpm$619$2@mughi.cs.ubc.ca:

> I have a Tungsten T2 running Mapopolis Navigator with their maps. It
> has a GPS mode where it receives continuous position updates from an
> external GPS receiver and plots your location on the map, scrolling the
> map as necessary. I've had all this working using the standard data
> cable for the GPS receiver, a serial hotsync cable for the Palm, and a
> 3-wire male-male null modem cable.

> However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps
> popping in and out of tracking. I think the problem is where the serial
> hotsync cable connects to the "universal connector" on the T2. This has
> got to be the worst design of connector I've ever seen for field use;
> nothing holds it together, or even holds the connector in the correct
> orientation to the Palm. There are no pins and sockets to connect each
> circuit; just a row of spring-loaded fingers and contact pads. I can
> see that it would work reasonably well in the charging stand, where the
> Palm is held at a fixed angle, but as a way of maintaining a connection
> on a portable/mobile piece of equipment it's just plain poor design.

Some cables are poorly designed. I use a charge/sync cable from Proporta,
which has a piece on the back that holds it against the Palm, and it's very
secure. It is a USB cable, though, and has to be modified in some way. You
can just cut the USB connector off and splice on the serial cable, or do what
I did, and splice the GPS cable into it, and use the USB connector to charge
both the Palm and the GPS through a cigarette-lighter charger that comes with
the kit. All you need from the GPS is data in, data out, and ground. The
PalmOne site has the pinouts, or I can send them to you if you like. Your
GPS manual should have the pinouts for it.

--
Regards,

Stan

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

"Jonas Lonnroth" <ispe_nospam@skynet.be> wrote in message news:<40b07fbe$0$9525$a0ced6e1@news.skynet.be>...

> All universal connectors are not equal.

Actually it is the other way round. All universal connectors should be
equal.
It is the sockets in different Palms that makes the difference.

The universal connectors that most cable makers use for Palm M5xx have
been working very well, until ...... Palm changed the designed of the
sockets slightly in Zire71 and most Tungstens. I do not think it was
intentional but the connectors that had been use with M5xx for so long
could not lock into Zire71/Tungstens because of the change in design.
I would rather think that it was a design flaw.

As a result the traditional "hook" type connectors would not hook into
the socket. It would slip. The only type of connectors that could lock
into Zire71/Tungsten satisfactorily is the "spring latch" type -
emulating the cradle type of connector.

We do have the "spring latch" type connectors for Zire71/Tungsten but
we make only a few more popular cables with this connector, not all.

Pc-Mobile
----------------------------
http://pc-mobile.net/gps.htm
Reply to gps2@pc-mobile.net

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

Dave Martindale schrieb:

> However, the connection seems to be very unreliable; Navigator keeps

There are about 4-5 different designs for the Universal Connector, and
Palm's own design is not among the best.

You should get a better connector or direct cable. Making your own cable
is trivial.

- Carsten

--
Audio Visual Systems fon: +49 (0)2234 601886
Carsten Kurz fax: +49 (0)2234 601887
Von-Werth-Straße 111 email: audiovisual@t-online.de
50259 Pulheim / Germany WGS84:N50°57'50.2" E06°47'28.5"

Reply to Anonymous

Archived from groups: comp.sys.palmtops.pilot,sci.geo.satellite-nav (More info?)

 

This solution should work:

Replace your hotsync cable + null modem adpter with PZ7SM(P) on:

http://pc-mobile.net/p500.htm

> Is there any solution to this? I suppose I could just get a serial
> hotsync cradle, and use something like a rubber band to keep the Palm in
> the cradle despite bumps in the car. Or is it possible to convert the
> serial NMEA data stream to infrared pulses in a format that the Palm's
> IR receiver can handle?
>
> Yes, I know I could buy a Bluetooth GPS receiver, but that's expensive
> and I don't want to buy another receiver. I want to use one of the ones
> I have.
>
> Dave

Pc-Mobile
-----------------
http://pc-mobile.net/gps.htm
Reply to: gps2@pc-mobile.net

Reply to Anonymous
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Smartphones & PDAs > Palmpilot > Need better serial data connection to Palm
Go to:

There are 1127 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them