It completely depends on you and your headphones and ears , you can hear well with either sb live value! or audigy or so on...
But when I started to upgrade my sound card (sb 16 first one),I first noticed trebles are better every upgrade. When I had live value!,trebles and bass are very good for gaming. Now I'm having fun with audigy. Trebles are better again and bass is more clear. I read from reviews that audigy2 has even better and clearer trebles and bass from audigy original. I played duke nukem,quake1,2,3 in past. And I have gave up gaming about 1-2 month ago. And bought a hifi system for connecting my computer. After that I always keep in mind that newer sound card=new tech and clearer treble&bass. Always upgrade your soundcard time to time and your headphones with the new models from the same manufacturer.
I would say audigy 2. Audigy 1 is available for $50 online in OEM form. Not bad. But for $100 shipped at newegg you get the audigy 2, hitman 2 full version and soldier of fortune 2 full version.. both have full eax advanced hd support.
I would have to say for the extra $50, those two games and a slightly superior sound card is definitly worth it.
but if you already had an original audigy like i do, i would say wait until the next creative card comes out.. because theres probably not enough difference to warrant an upgrade, they both sound great and have eax hd.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months. If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.