kyllien :
AS85 :
I completely disagree - Win8 is great for a touch interface for a tablet or phone but not for a laptop. I think they've got the Apple bug - they want to be hip and cool but people don't buy Windows to be cool - they do it to get work done. I'm willing to bet Win9 will revert back to the familiar interface - I can't see any business using this OS.
Anyhow, I just tried to install a trading application from Interactive Brokers and it is not launching.
How to get something done in Windows 8 from a work stand point? When you first start up and log in you click the Outlook program on the start screen. This takes you to the desktop in one click rather then the normal two clicks (or trying to click a really small icon on the taskbar). Other applications and webpages can be pinned to the taskbar for quick access while in desktop mode.
Also, the start page can be arranged anyway you see fit. You can even uninstall all the "Metro" apps except Store (which can be unpinned).
If the start page is still so horrible it can be removed and the archaic start menu restored by using third party programs like Start8.
While the new features flow better on a touch screen, they are not that difficult to get used to with a mouse and keyboard.
One example would be installing a trading software from Interactive Brokers. Normally in Win7, I would have just downloaded the file into my folder and I would be up and running. It wasn't so simple in Win8 - the file wasn't found by Windows - it couldn't determine the path???
Another example was opening a PDF. The new reader opens up like a smartphone app and dominates the whole screen. The goal is to swipe to the right and select options for sharing via email. Nice but too invasive IMO.
The basic question is - why eliminate the Start menu all together? Why not give users the option to use the Start menu or the Start screen. Better yet, why not use the old desktop but have live tiles on the desktop? They made a huge mistake by creating something so drastic. They should've done the above and then eventually eliminated Start later on as users like me became more comfortable with the UI.
What I meant by productivity work is that I find it difficult to manage multiple programs. I usually have 10-20 browser windows open along with Excel, Word, and my trading software. I found it difficult to manage these programs. Normally, I have them pinned to my Start menu, as opposed to the Desktop. This allows me to open them without having to minimize any open programs.
I still believe the UI is VERY GOOD for a tablet or phone. But for a PC, I would go with live tiles on the desktop itself.