Hi folks,
This is not a micing question...
I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
Thanks
Phil
--
Phil Oliver
Aardvark Graphics & Sound
remove _removespam for email replies
"Phil Oliver" <aardvarkgraphics_removespam@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:aardvarkgraphics_removespam-86EBFF.17511130082005@comcast.dca.giganews.com...
> Hi folks,
> This is not a micing question...
> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>
>
> Thanks
> Phil
Always had good luck with coated pin stripes on the batter side with clear
ambassadors on the bottoms of the larger toms. I like diplomats on the
smaller shells bottoms. Tune the bottom heads a fourth higher than the top
works for me. ymmv.
In general, there are a few choices for the top head....but I'd go for
a 2ply head on top. Unless you want to kill the overtones and sustain,
I'd continue to use a 1ply bottom head. With this setup there are
still a number of choices....white, black, clear, coated, pinstripe,
etc.
Later,
m
"Phil Oliver" <aardvarkgraphics_removespam@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:aardvarkgraphics_removespam-86EBFF.17511130082005@comcast.dca.giganews.
com...
> Hi folks,
> This is not a micing question...
> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>
>
> Thanks
> Phil
>
With Remo, stick with a clear Ambassador on the bottom, tuned medium-low,
and a coated Emperor, PS4 or Pinstripe on top, tuned wayyy low (just before
it starts going flappy). Seat the head first by cranking it up and applying
pressure to it, like slow CPR, then detune it. Don't be afraid to tune too
low - you can always tune up again if it sounds bad! The only caveat is that
low tunings make it easier for drummers to dent the heads if they have bad
technique.
If you prefer Evans/Aquarian, ask your drum shop for their equivalents.
I'll also go with Remo Pinstripe. The Ebony heads are a little warmer
sounding (less overtones). I'm using Remo Renaissance heads for the
bottom. They're a little heavier and can be tuned deeper.
Alternately, I would use an Emperor uncoated on the bottom. The
heavier the head, the lower the lowest tuning will be.
I also put an X of gaff tape on the top heads, in the center (two
pieces about 3 inches square) - not on the edge like most drummers do.
This makes the top head heavier in the center, and allows it to go a
good bit deeper (without being flabby). It actually increases the ring
of the fundamental tone a bit (but cuts out the overtones). This is
like the tone spot on tabla drums. You can also do this with the
bottom head (I use only one piece for this).
To get the deepest sound, I tune both heads to the same note, Start
by tuning the top head a little low and flabby and slowly tune up to
the point that it has an adequate bounce to the stick. Then do the
bottom head to match (and then go back and forth a couple of times to
get them just the same).
When recording, I try to use mics with more low end. I use Audio
Technica ATM 25's. They're often used for kick drums as well as toms.
AKG 112 work as well (especially on the floor tom), as would most bass
drum mics. Back these mics off the drum head about 4 - 5 inches (or
you'll get too much bass to handle). You'll be amazed at how much more
deep and mellow the drums can sound with this kind of mic. If you
don't have mics like these you can spare for the toms, try putting the
mic as close to the head (to increase proximity) and a little more
toward the center of the head that usual (that's where the low sound
will come from - not the rim).
Phil Oliver wrote:
> Hi folks,
> This is not a micing question...
> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>
>
> Thanks
> Phil
>
Remo pinstripes on top, single skin on bottom.
Tuning:
Buy a "Drumdial" tuning aid. Yeah, they're about sixty bucks, but you'll be able to literally tune
the head perfectly. Ears get fatigued (a sad reality); using this to tune the heads removes your
ears from having to listen to the constant tap tap tap as you tune around the head to even out the
pressure.
For example, I have a six piece Yamaha World Studio kit, 5 ply maple; the low tom is tuned to 78 lbs
on the top head and 76 lbs on the bottom head. No flab, nice and tight and good tone. You play
around with it to get the "note" you want, but once you get it, you just have to remember the
pressure setting on the gauge -- particularly when changing heads -- and it will always be the same.
"Phil Oliver" <aardvarkgraphics_removespam@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:aardvarkgraphics_removespam-86EBFF.17511130082005@comcast.dca.giganews.com...
> Hi folks,
> This is not a micing question...
> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>
>
> Thanks
> Phil
>
> --
> Phil Oliver
> Aardvark Graphics & Sound
> remove _removespam for email replies
Yup, like most everyone else I usually use Remo clear emperors on top and
clear Ambassadors on the bottom. Pick up a tub or two of MoonGel to
selectively kill some of the overtones/ring if desired. For less brightness
try the Remo Renaissance style heads. Evans hydraulic ( do they still make
those??? ) can go pretty low but tend to not sustain as well as the
Emperors, especially at the lower range of tuning . . . which may or may not
be a good thing for you.
Phil Oliver wrote:
> Hi folks,
> This is not a micing question...
> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>
>
> Thanks
> Phil
>
> --
> Phil Oliver
> Aardvark Graphics & Sound
> remove _removespam for email replies
I recommend Aquarian heads. I endorse them and believe that they are a
superior head due to more consistent mylar and better bonding in the
outside collars. I got fed up with Remo heads pulling out and sounding
different from head to head even when they were supposedly the same
size and thickness.
The Aquarian equivalent (better than equal to) of an Emperor 2-ply head
is the "Response 2". Aquarian's version of the Pinstripe is called
"Peformance 2". It has less overtone than the Response 2. I prefer the
normal 2-ply head without the ring for damping. By the time it is
mixed, you rarely hear any overtone if the drum is tuned and mixed
properly.
I disagree with the concept of tuning the bottom head a fourth higher.
Use a single ply head on the bottom and tune it close to the top head
to avoid phase cancellation. Why would you want a membrane in the same
cabinet to vibrate at a much faster rate the other membrane. When
speaker cabinets use "passive drivers to accentuate the low end of the
active speaker, they are complimentary in flexibility, not a whole lot
tighter.
For big low sounds, choose big diameter drums with a depth the same or
slightly less than the diameter. Birch drums are universally
recognized as having a deeper tone than Maple. Mahogany has still
different characteristics. Tune the top double ply head low but not low
enough to distort. Tune the single ply bottom head near the same
tightness as the top head. If you have to use a tightness gauge, you
are probably not the best person to tune the drums. EQ-ing the toms is
also critical. Drop the EQ at 400-500 Hz and it will bring out the
bottom below those frequencies. Then try adding a little at 4K for
attack. Micing can make a difference in the depth of the drum if the
proximity effect of the mic is pronounced. Sennheiser 421's are hard to
beat (no pun intended).
I tune my toms in 3rds 4ths 5ths or octaves apart from each other
whenever I can so that the overtones of the toms do not form "beats"
like a perfect 2nd or half-step do. I have had many compliments on my
tuning, recorded several major label albums and hundreds of demos and
independent albums. I am a Pearl, Zildjian and Vater endorser as well.
This is not to brag (OK, I guess I bragged) but to lend validity to my
rants.
Recently I recorded numerous takes of the same drum beat using
different ribbon mics for engineer Lynn Fuston using one mic at a time
in exactly the same position. When he added some compression to certain
mics, it was amazing! It sounded very John Bonham-ish. You can hear
some of that at Lynn's website 3daudio.com. His reviews are also in the
current EQ magazine.
<peakester@earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:1125560110.343606.146690@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
>
> Phil Oliver wrote:
>> Hi folks,
>> This is not a micing question...
>> I've got an upcoming session where we're looking for a big, really low
>> tom sound. So, I'm looking for suggestions on drum heads that can get
>> real low with decent sustain, lots of fundamental, minimal overtones,
>> without sounding flabby (for lack of a better word).
>>
>>
>> Thanks
>> Phil
>>
>> --
>> Phil Oliver
>> Aardvark Graphics & Sound
>> remove _removespam for email replies
>
> I recommend Aquarian heads. I endorse them and believe that they are a
> superior head due to more consistent mylar and better bonding in the
> outside collars. I got fed up with Remo heads pulling out and sounding
> different from head to head even when they were supposedly the same
> size and thickness.
>
> The Aquarian equivalent (better than equal to) of an Emperor 2-ply head
> is the "Response 2". Aquarian's version of the Pinstripe is called
> "Peformance 2". It has less overtone than the Response 2. I prefer the
> normal 2-ply head without the ring for damping. By the time it is
> mixed, you rarely hear any overtone if the drum is tuned and mixed
> properly.
>
> I disagree with the concept of tuning the bottom head a fourth higher.
> Use a single ply head on the bottom and tune it close to the top head
> to avoid phase cancellation. Why would you want a membrane in the same
> cabinet to vibrate at a much faster rate the other membrane. When
> speaker cabinets use "passive drivers to accentuate the low end of the
> active speaker, they are complimentary in flexibility, not a whole lot
> tighter.
Hi Andy,
Nice to see you here and congrats and respect for your accomplishments!
I'll give the "Response 2"s a try. I also have never liked the 'epoxy'
method Remo uses to hold the head to the collar. ( I prefer Ludwig's
crimping method much better ).
Tuning the bottom head up a fourth is effective at controlling sustain. If
the heads are tuned the same, the sustain may be too long, by tuning up a
fourth the bottom head is mainly excited by the upper harmonics and not the
fundamental frequency of the batter head. This usually works well for me as
I don't normally use any dampening on the toms and I play a lot of prog rock
with often fast/complex tom patterns and too much sustain would get in the
way.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months. If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.