Archived from groups: rec.audio.pro (
More info?)
Miss_Me <andiet@microboards.com> wrote:
>
>First, is the CD burner you are using of professional standard? There
>are many brands of CD burners on the market, but there are a limited
>few that would be considered a quality recorder. These professional
>standard recorders include Plextor, Teac, and Sanyo to name a few.
This can affect the error rate, but sometimes you'll be surprised.
One given machine might have a lower error rate than some other machine,
and it's not always predictable.
>The next factor to look at is what is the quality of the CD-R media you
>are using? As with recorders, there are some good manufacturers and
>there are some bad manufacturers. We recommend Taiyo Yuden as the best
>quality piece of media on the market.
This is currently true, but it might not be true next week. And you
might find that some other media give lower error rates WITH YOUR
PARTICULAR RECORDER than the TYs. Now that the Mitsuis have changed,
this is less likely to be the case, but it can be.
>Assuming you are using a professional recorder with professional media,
>there should not be a noticeable difference in your audio quality. Some
>have claimed to hear audible differences between discs burned at lower
>speeds and those burned. Many times, this is due to poor quality media,
>a low-end recorder, or both. For all practical purposes, there will be
>no audible difference between 16X and 52X recorded CD-Rs.
Maybe. Maybe not. You need to measure error rates before doing
anything else, and that means Plextools, or an instrumented player
like the Meridian box.
Until you actually measure the error rates, you are just shooting in
the dark.
--scott
--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."