G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: rec.games.chess.computer (More info?)
I have found some discrepancies between Fundamental Chess Endings and
Fritz with the endgame tablebases (and online tablebases), for endings
with no pawns, in "Table of Computer Database Results for Pawnless
Endings", at the end of FCE by Muller and Lamprecht.
For instance, F&M give this as a win for white in 10 moves: w: K8,
Qg8; b: Kb8, Qa8, white to move. I was wondering if this was 10 moves
to win the queen or 10 moves to checkmate. Neither, according to
Fritz with tablebases and online tablebase! White wins the queen on
move 8 but checkmates on move 13.
This came up because I was looking at Q vs. 2N, and K&M give a
position as the longest win for white, in 63 moves. I was wondering
if this was 63 moves to simplify, or 63 to mate (because I was
wondering if a captured occurred within 50 moves). According to Fritz
with the tablebase, a knight is won on move 57 and mate is achieved on
move 72.
A similar one is Q vs. 2B. K&M give a position that is the longest
win for white, in 71 moves. Fritz says that a bishop is won on move
72.
Another one is Q vs. R. F&M give white's longest win as 31 moves, but
the rook is won on move 22 and mate is on move 30.
So, which of these sources is right? I assume that Fritz with the
tablebase is more likely to be correct, but why are there so many
discrepancies between it an FCE on just the few positions I checked?
---
Replace you know what by j to email
I have found some discrepancies between Fundamental Chess Endings and
Fritz with the endgame tablebases (and online tablebases), for endings
with no pawns, in "Table of Computer Database Results for Pawnless
Endings", at the end of FCE by Muller and Lamprecht.
For instance, F&M give this as a win for white in 10 moves: w: K8,
Qg8; b: Kb8, Qa8, white to move. I was wondering if this was 10 moves
to win the queen or 10 moves to checkmate. Neither, according to
Fritz with tablebases and online tablebase! White wins the queen on
move 8 but checkmates on move 13.
This came up because I was looking at Q vs. 2N, and K&M give a
position as the longest win for white, in 63 moves. I was wondering
if this was 63 moves to simplify, or 63 to mate (because I was
wondering if a captured occurred within 50 moves). According to Fritz
with the tablebase, a knight is won on move 57 and mate is achieved on
move 72.
A similar one is Q vs. 2B. K&M give a position that is the longest
win for white, in 71 moves. Fritz says that a bishop is won on move
72.
Another one is Q vs. R. F&M give white's longest win as 31 moves, but
the rook is won on move 22 and mate is on move 30.
So, which of these sources is right? I assume that Fritz with the
tablebase is more likely to be correct, but why are there so many
discrepancies between it an FCE on just the few positions I checked?
---
Replace you know what by j to email