ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
I could do it externally with a Dolby Prologic decoder, but this is
eight hours of audio. I need to do it as a batch job.
This comes up often enough that I need a permanent cure.
<Kurt Riemann> wrote in message
news:gfc9i11kh42v01g8a36epkopo1fs8ulbkv@4ax.com...
> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
>
> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
>
> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
Take the "vocal eliminated" track and inverse that against the standard mono
sum?
Kurt Riemann wrote:
> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
>
> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
>
> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
>
> I could do it externally with a Dolby Prologic decoder, but this is
> eight hours of audio. I need to do it as a batch job.
>
> This comes up often enough that I need a permanent cure.
In article <3ok4arF64ca9U1@individual.net>, merlin@merlinsound.de
says...
>
> Put the Waves MS-Matrix on the stereo track and bus the track=3Fs output to
> e.g. busses 1-2.
> What=3Fs coming in on bus 1 is the M signal only.
No... M is L + R. What he wants is, essentially:
unabs(abs(L + R) - abs(L - R)).
And since there's no way to "unabs" a signal, the only way to do this is
brute force - take an FFT of the signal stream, figure out what's in
each channel, note the common frequencies, and save only those.
Dolby Pro-Logic sort of does this, and I believe Adobe Audition does it.
I haven't heard of any plugins for Pro-Tools that do it.
Do a Google Groups search for much, much more on the topic.
--
Jay Levitt |
Wellesley, MA | I feel calm. I feel ready. I can only
Faster: jay at jay dot fm | conclude that's because I don't have a
http://www.jay.fm | full grasp of the situation. - Mark Adler
On Sun, 11 Sep 2005 19:27:34 -0400, "Zigakly" <no@no.no> wrote:
>
><Kurt Riemann> wrote in message
>news:gfc9i11kh42v01g8a36epkopo1fs8ulbkv@4ax.com...
>> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
>>
>> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
>> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
>> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
>>
>> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
>> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
>> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
>> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
>
>Take the "vocal eliminated" track and inverse that against the standard mono
>sum?
>
No, Left would sum with the "vical eliminated" track because left was
never inverted in either process. So any noise on the left would be
reinforced, not eliminated.
Kurt Riemann wrote:
> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
>
> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
>
> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
>
> I could do it externally with a Dolby Prologic decoder, but this is
> eight hours of audio. I need to do it as a batch job.
>
> This comes up often enough that I need a permanent cure.
>
>
>
>
> Thanks -
>
> Kurt Riemann
this is an interesting question...
sounds like what you need is some kind of correlation filter that
passes only signal that is the same in both L and R.
On 9/11/05 10:12 PM, in article
1126491160.482356.243410@z14g2000cwz.googlegroups.com, "Mark"
<makolber@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> Kurt Riemann wrote:
>> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
>>
>> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
>> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
>> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
>>
>> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
>> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
>> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
>> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
>>
>> I could do it externally with a Dolby Prologic decoder, but this is
>> eight hours of audio. I need to do it as a batch job.
>>
>> This comes up often enough that I need a permanent cure.
Dang it we just DID this thread a few weeks back.
Dolby Pro Logic can derive a SORT of center-only channel but that it can do
it at all is damned amazing, and it's hardly perfect. Beyond that, you
pretty much can't... Though as a forensics job you're not concerned with
perfection.
What dedicated forensic audio tools are you using?
There are a couple systems that can dig through this with some success, if
you've had no success with them then there may not be a better result.
Kurt Riemann <Kurt Riemann> wrote:
>
>So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
>right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
>the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
>this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
If the noise isn't correlated, you can't.
If the noise is common to both channels, you can subtract the two and
get only the difference. Then you can pick one channel, and subtract
varying amounts of that. It sort of works.
--scott
--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
On Sun, 11 Sep 2005 18:08:15 -0800, Kurt Riemann <> wrote:
>>Take the "vocal eliminated" track and inverse that against the standard mono
>>sum?
>>
>
>No, Left would sum with the "vocal eliminated" track because left was
>never inverted in either process. So any noise on the left would be
>reinforced, not eliminated.
Yeah, the Dolby stuff includes gain-riding. No amount
of summing and differencing can do any better than
L+R and L-R. Ain't (as you point out) there.
<Kurt Riemann> wrote in message
newsbo9i15vprquqmjeqnnbh16otpsmgbi3p2@4ax.com...
> On Sun, 11 Sep 2005 19:27:34 -0400, "Zigakly" <no@no.no> wrote:
>
> >
> ><Kurt Riemann> wrote in message
> >news:gfc9i11kh42v01g8a36epkopo1fs8ulbkv@4ax.com...
> >> ProTools - how can I reduce a stereo file to center image only?
> >>
> >> Everyone knows the phase flip trick that removes all information
> >> common to left and right channels. (left summed with out-of-phase
> >> right channel.) It's the poor man's vocal elimination trick.
> >>
> >> So I'm stymied - how can I remove information NOT common to left and
> >> right? I'm doing a forensics job and there is video tracking noise in
> >> the left and right channels, and it's not in the center. Any way to do
> >> this? I have a full Waves collection and a few Digi plugs.
> >
> >Take the "vocal eliminated" track and inverse that against the standard
mono
> >sum?
> >
>
> No, Left would sum with the "vical eliminated" track because left was
> never inverted in either process. So any noise on the left would be
> reinforced, not eliminated.
Ah, you're right. You can't solve for three variables with only two
equations.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months. If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.