Tom's Hardware > Forum > Tom's Guide > Article Discussions > All You Need To Know About Ripping DVDs
Word :    Username :           
 

Sooner or later, you\'re going to need to rip a DVD. Mary Branscombe provides some tips for how to get the job done right and avoid getting scammed for ripping software.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Been Archiving DVD's since '98-what used to take ,Literaly DAYS-Now Takes MINUTES!! (pardon caps!) The arctickle referenced is chock-full-a information that is practically useless to the Beginner ! Get AnyDVD Trial Download and search web for DVDShrink 3.2 or CloneDVD2. Play with these apps for a few days,you should be amazed at what you learn and MORE IMPORTANTLY-Exactly what you need to learn to do what you want !

Reply to tiotaitch
- 0 +

Why is there no mention of using Slysoft's products? I have found that using AnyDVD and CloneDVD are an unbeatable combination!

Reply to segap21
- 0 +

What is the native resolution for a regular singel layer DVD?

Reply to fishboi

I'd look into using a more modern codec such as h264 which could take some work. Unfortunately I didn't see support for this codec in the programs mentioned in the article. Also, using 2pass VBR can really help boost quality. A 2.3GB DivX file? Wow. I'm not trying to be disrespectful, but that's probably a bit excessive. Past a certain point, boosting the bitrate doesn't really help video quality that much on most codecs. Also, "quality" is a very subjective term. Unfortunately, the best advice I can offer you is to try several different settings and see what suits your taste. This can be time consuming and tedious, but its better than: "Hey this dude told me settings X, Y, and Z were good, but Ithey don't live up to my expectations." Doom9 looks like a good source of info.

-mcg

Reply to MrCommunistGen

I'm confused on the part of the article that says using DVD decrypter for the encoding and DVD Shrink for the burning.

DVD shrink doesn't have any burning capabilities unless you combine it with Nero (burningROM, etc) for disc burning.

I use DVDShrink for the whole process. I know it can turn it into an ISO which Nero can later burn (the free versions of Roxio 6 that I have don't allow this) or it can be kept as VOB files which can be played with and recombined for episode type things, which I havent gotten into myself yet.

I think I tried DVD Decrypter and found it cumbersome to use, but I don't remember which version that was.

Reply to the_taker
- 0 +

Some good points. Thanks.

Reply to fishboi

Quote :

Why is there no mention of using Slysoft's products? I have found that using AnyDVD and CloneDVD are an unbeatable combination!



Same comment than segap21. For DivX compression, what about Dr. DivX ?

Reply to Bill_Boquet

This article most certainly is NOT all you need to know about ripping DVDs. While it might give you some ideas about programs to use for ripping DVDs it doesn't really give any basic recommendations as far as what to do once you've ripped the DVD. You typically don't just rip a DVD, you then encode it into Divx or Xvid or something.

And as a previous poster mentions, it doesn't even say anything about Dr. Divx! Dr. Divx is the easiest Divx program to use and in my experience does a better job than Gordian Knot or anything else I'm aware of. And did I mention it's super easy to use? :)

This article needs to be retitled - Helpful Hints about ripping DVDs. There's still a lot of good information is this article. Just not everything.

Reply to foshizzle

DVD Decrypter was not purchased by Macrovision.
Macrovision and others sued Lightning UK! (author) and forced
him to stop development and support of decrypting software.
He has since authored imageburn, but that only burns and does not
rip.

I convert most of my DVD's into X264 files and they look great at 1/2 the size or less. I play them on my HTPC.

Tom's Hardware is great for many things, but for the real deal on video check out Doom9.org.

Most of the authors of the programs mentioned and more hang out there, including Lightning UK!

Mark

Reply to markrb12
- 0 +

What is X264 conversion?

Reply to fishboi
- 0 +

I figured out that VLC Media Player is the software.

Reply to fishboi
- 0 +

Has anyone used this program before?

Reply to fishboi
- 0 +

How large on average would you say a 1280X1024 native resolution, H.264 encoded MPEG would be?

Reply to fishboi
- 0 +

I'm happy SOMEONE is openly talking about this.
Just the portible video players are useless unless I can get the DVD video in there.
I feel the same about UMPCs. Great devices, but the limited wireless access broadband make them useless.

I am surprised big companies like Apple and Sony arn't pushing video content copying. Media devices require some kind of copying. They want to sell portible media players and no one wants to buy media that can only work on one device. Right?

Reply to enewmen

I am an intellectual property attorney who reads Tom's regularly. For this article, Tom's should really get a legal opinion before inducing mass contributory copyright infringement under the DMCA (there is a difference between ripping a CD and DVD - a CD isn't encrypted and doesn't fall under the DMCA). Althoug fair use exists under section 107 of the Copyright statute, the DMCA exists independent of fair use and makes no allownace for it. This article hits a *really* gray area regarding contributing to the anti-circumvention sections of the DMCA. See the 9-0 Supreme Court Grokster opinion regarding the current sentiment for contributorily inducing infringement.

Although your article might be fine, it is an unsettled area of the law that could come back to sting THG. I'm not expert here nor your lawyer, but given the fact that it is unlikely that any of the software solutions cited in the article have actually licensed the DVD DRM keys and given the severity of fines under the DMCA anti-circumvention sections, you may want to reconsider this article unless you have a legal opinion.

Two cents from somebody who wants to see THG continue without the interference of Hollywood who is probably itching for a sacrificial victim to go after in this very area...

Reply to cilantro13

Rob said:

Quote :

Another really good tool is www.dvd-wmv.com It is free and works great although limited to WMV output. Worth mentioning though.

Reply to thiggins

I think you might still be able to get DVD Decrypter through P2P.

Reply to this_is_jimmy2006

I noticed the lack of Slysoft's programs also. I have used DvdDecryptor, DVDshrink and now I use AnyDVD from Slysoft, which works the best for me so far. I noticed recently that the first 2 I mentioned are having trouble ripping the newest DVDs out even after updating the software(decryptor not available I think), which is why I started using AnyDVD. I still use Shrink for repackaging though.

Reply to Col_Frost

Quote :


Two cents from somebody who wants to see THG continue without the interference of Hollywood who is probably itching for a sacrificial victim to go after in this very area...



Plenty of people have already been victimized by Hollywood, but that will probably never stop them from scratching that itch.

Reply to johnniewalker

Quote :

Another really good tool is dvd-wmv.com It is free and works great although limited to WMV output. Worth mentioning though.



I also agree that an excellent site for reference is http://www.dvd-to-wmv.com

Reply to spoonfed
- 0 +


Google it?

http://www.dvdtowmvconverter.com/

Never used it, but I am intrigued now . . .

Reply to evorod
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Tom's Guide > Article Discussions > All You Need To Know About Ripping DVDs
Go to:

There are 1305 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them